Human Performance · Chapter 35
Man and Machine, Decisions and CRM How the flight deck is designed around people, the benefits and dangers of automation, making decisions and judging risk, reporting incidents, and crew resource management.
140 3000 © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Chapter thirty-five, the last Human Performance lesson, brings the subject together. We look at how flight decks are designed to fit people, using the SHELL model, then at automation and its traps, how pilots make decisions and judge risk, why incident reporting and a just culture matter, and finally crew resource management and threat and error management.
Man and machine
The SHELL model The pilot, Liveware , sits at the centre and must match each surrounding element Software : procedures, checklists, charts, symbolsHardware : controls, displays, seats, warningsEnvironment : noise, light, temperature, weather, the organisationLiveware : other people, crew, ATC, engineers; where mismatches cause many accidents L Liveware (you) S Software procedures, checklists H Hardware controls, displays E Environment cockpit, weather L Liveware crew, ATC
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The SHELL model shows how a pilot fits into the system. At the centre is the pilot, the liveware. Around it are four elements, and each edge must match the person well. Software is the procedures, checklists, charts and symbols; badly written procedures or confusing symbols cause errors. Hardware is the physical flight deck: controls, displays, seats and warning systems. Environment covers the conditions inside and outside the cockpit, from noise, light and temperature to weather and even the organisation. And the other liveware is the people the pilot works with: the other crew members, controllers and engineers. Many accidents come from a mismatch at the liveware-liveware edge, which is what crew resource management addresses.
Design
Designing for people Eye reference point Set the seat so your eyes are at the design eye position : view over the nose and of all instruments.
Displays Clear, standard layout (the basic T); glass cockpits and HUDs keep key data in view.
gear: wheel flap: wing move the expected way Controls Shaped and placed so they cannot be confused; move the expected way (stereotypes ).
WARNING CAUTION red warning · amber caution Warnings Reliable, not false; get attention, then tell you what is wrong; red warning, amber caution.
Checklists Read and do properly, not rushed from memory.
Anthropometry Design to fit the range of human body sizes, usually 5th to 95th percentile.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Good flight deck design fits the person. Adjust your seat so your eyes are at the design eye reference point, which gives you the intended view over the nose and of every instrument; sitting low can hide the runway at the flare. Displays follow a clear, standard layout, such as the basic T, and glass cockpits and head-up displays keep the key information in view. Controls are shaped and placed so they cannot be confused, and move the way people expect, called population stereotypes. Warning systems must be reliable, without false alarms that teach crews to ignore them; they should first get your attention and then tell you what is wrong, with red for warnings and amber for cautions. Checklists should be read and done properly, not rushed through from memory. And designers use body measurements, anthropometry, to fit most people, usually from the fifth to the ninety-fifth percentile.
Automation
A tool, not a replacement Benefits + lower routine workload + flies precisely and economically + protection against limits + frees the crew to think aheadALT HOLD V/S Dangers − complacency, passive monitoring − mode errors: “what’s it doing now?” − loss of manual handling skill − workload spike when it failsComplacency Over-trust; passive monitoring ; errors not noticed.
Mode error Believing the system is in one mode when it is in another; check the mode annunciator.
Skill fade Hand-fly regularly to keep manual skills.
The rule Use the level of automation that suits the moment, and always know what it is doing.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Automation is there to assist the pilot, not to replace them. It lowers routine workload, flies precisely and economically, protects against exceeding limits, and frees the crew to think ahead. But it brings dangers. Complacency, or over-trust, leads to passive monitoring, where errors go unnoticed. Mode errors happen when the crew believes the system is in one mode while it is actually in another, often heard as, what is it doing now; always check the flight mode annunciator. Manual flying skills fade if they are never used, so hand-fly regularly. And when automation fails, workload jumps suddenly, often at the worst moment. The rule is to use the level of automation that suits the situation, and always know what it is doing.
Making decisions
A simple structured model F Facts what is happening? O Options what can we do? R Risks and benefits DE Decide agree a plan E Execute share tasks C Check is it working? then back to the factsWhy a model Under stress we jump to conclusions; a structure slows us just enough.
Facts first Gather information before choosing; beware confirmation bias.
Time If time allows, use it: fly the aircraft, then decide.
Review Keep checking; be ready to change the plan.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Under stress, people tend to jump to the first solution that comes to mind, so crews use simple decision models. One widely used model is FOR-DEC: gather the Facts, list the Options, weigh the Risks and benefits, Decide, Execute the plan with tasks shared out, and Check whether it is working, then go back to the facts. Gather information before choosing, and watch for confirmation bias. If time allows, use it: fly the aircraft first, then decide calmly. And keep reviewing the decision, ready to change the plan if the situation changes.
Risk How likely something is, combined with how bad it would be.
familiar: under-rated ! dramatic: over-rated Perception We under-rate familiar risks and over-rate rare dramatic ones.
Pressure Commercial, time and peer pressure push us to accept more risk.
press-on-itis nearly there… Plan-continuation “Press-on-itis”: the closer to the goal, the harder it is to change the plan.
MY MINIMA decided on the ground Personal minima Decide your limits on the ground, before the pressure arrives.
go around: never a failure Go-around Always an option, and never a failure.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Risk combines how likely something is with how bad it would be if it happened. People judge risk poorly: we under-rate familiar risks, such as driving, and over-rate rare, dramatic ones. Commercial pressure, time pressure and the wish not to let others down push pilots to accept more risk. Plan-continuation bias, often called press-on-itis, makes it harder to change the plan the closer we are to the goal, which is why so many accidents happen near the destination. Set your personal minima on the ground, before the pressure arrives, and remember that a go-around or diversion is always an option and never a failure.
Reporting
Learning from incidents Why report Many incidents happen for every accident; learn from them before the accident.
REPORT DGCA AAIB if serious Mandatory Occurrences that must be reported to DGCA; in India also to AAIB if serious.
Voluntary Confidential reports of errors and hazards; India has a voluntary reporting system.
honest error reckless learn punished Just culture Honest errors are not punished; reckless acts and wilful violations are.
Active and latent Active failures happen at the sharp end; latent conditions wait in the system.
Error tolerance Design systems so a single error cannot cause disaster.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
For every accident there are many incidents, and each is a chance to learn before the accident happens. Some occurrences must be reported, to DGCA and, if serious, to the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau. Other reports are voluntary and confidential, letting people describe their own errors and hazards they have seen, and India runs such a voluntary reporting system. This works only in a just culture, where honest errors are not punished but reckless behaviour and wilful violations are. Reports reveal both active failures, made at the sharp end in the cockpit, and latent conditions, hidden weaknesses in the system that wait for the right moment. The aim is error-tolerant systems, where no single error can lead to disaster.
CRM
Crew resource management and TEM CRM Using all resources, people, equipment and information, to fly safely; required training in India.
communication teamwork leadership awareness decisions workload Skills Communication, teamwork, leadership, situational awareness, decision-making, workload management.
Threats Things outside the crew’s control: weather, terrain, ATC, technical faults, other traffic.
intended error: drifts away Errors Crew actions or inactions that lead away from what was intended.
Undesired state An unsafe aircraft position, speed or configuration; recover it quickly.
TEM Anticipate threats, recognise errors, recover before an undesired state.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Crew resource management means using all available resources, people, equipment and information, to fly safely, and it is required training for airline crews in India. Its skills are communication, teamwork, leadership, situational awareness, decision-making and workload management. Threat and error management builds on it. Threats are things outside the crew’s control, such as weather, terrain, air traffic control, technical faults or other traffic. Errors are crew actions or inactions that lead away from what was intended. If threats and errors are not managed, they can lead to an undesired aircraft state, such as being off the correct path, too fast or wrongly configured. The idea is to anticipate threats, recognise errors early, and recover before an undesired state develops into an incident or accident.
Summary
What to take into the exam SHELL Software, Hardware, Environment, Liveware around the central Liveware.
WARNING CAUTION red warning · amber caution Design Eye reference point; stereotypes; reliable warnings; red warning, amber caution.
ALT HOLD V/S which mode is it in? Automation Complacency, mode error, skill fade, workload spike on failure.
F O R D E C facts · options · risks decide · execute · check Decisions FOR-DEC: facts, options, risks, decide, execute, check.
honest error reckless learn punished Reporting Mandatory and voluntary; just culture; active and latent failures.
CRM / TEM Use all resources. Threats, errors, undesired states.
Chapter 35 · Man and Machine, Decision-Making and CRM
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To sum up. The SHELL model places the pilot at the centre, surrounded by software, hardware, environment and other liveware. Good design sets your eyes at the reference point, follows control stereotypes, and uses reliable warnings, red for warnings and amber for cautions. Automation brings complacency, mode errors, skill fade and a sudden rise in workload when it fails. Decisions can follow FOR-DEC: facts, options, risks and benefits, decide, execute and check. Incident reporting, mandatory and voluntary, works only in a just culture, and reveals both active and latent failures. And crew resource management uses all resources, while threat and error management deals with threats, errors and undesired aircraft states. That completes Part B; the final lesson is revision.