IFR Training · Chapter 12
Circling and Minima Landing on a different runway from the one you approached, and the visibility rules that govern every take-off and landing.
Instrument approach to runway 09 Downwind · runway in sight Base turn Land runway 27 N © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Sometimes the instrument approach brings you to one runway, but the wind demands that you land on another. The answer is to circle: to fly a low, tight, visual circuit under the cloud, keeping the runway in sight all the way round. It is one of the most demanding manoeuvres in instrument flying. In this last lesson we look at circling, and then at the minima that decide whether you may take off, start an approach, or land at all.
Roadmap
A visual circuit under the cloud, and the rules of visibility Circling A visual manoeuvre after an instrument approach, inside a protected area .
If you lose sight A climbing turn towards the runway , then the missed approach.
Take-off minima Enough visibility to keep straight, and a plan if you must return .
Landing minima RVR , the approach ban , and what you must see to land.
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
There are four parts. Circling, with its protected area and how to fly it. What to do if you lose sight of the runway. Then take off minima. And finally landing minima: runway visual range, the approach ban, and what you must actually see in order to land.
Circling
An instrument approach followed by a visual circuit Used when the approach is not aligned with the landing runway, or the wind favours another runway Fly the instrument approach down to the circling MDA , which is higher than the straight-in minima Once visual, break off and manoeuvre to a downwind or base position Stay at or above the circling MDA until a normal descent to the runway can be madeKeep the runway environment in sight throughout It is a visual manoeuvre flown in marginal weather, at low level, in landing configuration Instrument approach to runway 09 Downwind · runway in sight Base turn Land runway 27 N
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
A circling approach is used when the instrument approach is not lined up with the runway you need to land on, usually because of the wind. You fly the instrument approach down to the circling minimum descent altitude, which is higher than the straight in minima. Once you have the runway in sight, you break off and manoeuvre visually to a downwind or base position for the landing runway. You stay at or above the circling altitude until you are in a position to make a normal descent to the runway. And you keep the runway environment in sight the whole time. Remember what this is: a visual manoeuvre, flown in marginal weather, at low level, in the landing configuration. It deserves respect.
The protected area
Circling area and minima by aircraft category Category Speed at threshold (VAT) Max circling speed Radius from each threshold Obstacle clearance Lowest OCH Minimum visibility A Below 91 kt 100 kt 1.68 NM 295 ft (90 m) 394 ft 1.9 km B 91 to 120 kt 135 kt 2.66 NM 295 ft (90 m) 492 ft 2.8 km C 121 to 140 kt 180 kt 4.20 NM 394 ft (120 m) 591 ft 3.7 km D 141 to 165 kt 205 kt 5.28 NM 394 ft (120 m) 689 ft 4.6 km E 166 to 210 kt 240 kt 6.94 NM 492 ft (150 m) 787 ft 6.5 km
The area is drawn with arcs of this radius from each runway threshold , joined by tangents. VAT is 1.3 × the stalling speed in the landing configuration at maximum landing mass. Fly faster than your category allows and you may leave the protected area.
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Obstacle clearance while circling is only guaranteed inside the circling area. It is drawn by swinging an arc from the threshold of every runway and joining the arcs with straight lines, and the radius of the arc depends on your aircraft category. Categories are set by the speed at the threshold, which is one point three times the stalling speed in the landing configuration. For category A, below ninety one knots, the radius is only one point six eight nautical miles. For category B it is two point six six, for category C four point two, and for category D five point two eight. The lesson is clear. If you fly faster than your category speed, or let the circuit drift wide, you may leave the protected area without knowing it.
Technique
How to fly the circle Brief it Which way will you break? Which side keeps the runway on the pilot's side ? Any sectors where circling is prohibited ?
Configure early Gear down, approach flap, circling speed before you break off. Landing flap on final.
Stay tight Fly a normal circuit pattern but closer in . Use up to about 25° of bank, and time the downwind if it helps.
Hold the altitude Level at the circling MDA. Scan: runway, altimeter, speed , and back to the runway.
Descend late Leave the MDA only when you can make a normal approach at a normal rate to the touchdown zone.
Any doubt Runway lost, or not stable on final: missed approach .
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
How do you fly it? Brief it first. Decide which way you will break, which direction keeps the runway on your side of the cockpit, and whether the chart prohibits circling in any sector. Configure early: landing gear down, approach flap and circling speed before you break off, with landing flap selected on final. Stay tight. Fly a normal circuit shape, but closer in, using up to about twenty five degrees of bank. Hold the circling altitude exactly, and keep your scan moving between the runway, the altimeter and the airspeed. Descend late: leave the circling altitude only when you can make a normal approach at a normal rate of descent to the touchdown zone. And if there is any doubt, go around.
Losing sight
Runway lost: climbing turn towards the runway If visual reference is lost at any point in the circle, a missed approach is mandatory Start a climbing turn towards the landing runway This keeps you inside the circling area, over the aerodrome, while you gain height Continue the turn until overhead the aerodrome , then establish on the missed approach track of the instrument approach you flew Not the missed approach of the runway you were circling to Tell ATC as soon as the aircraft is safely climbing Downwind Climbing turn towards the runway Join the missed approach N
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
What if you lose sight of the runway? At any point in the circle, losing the visual reference means a missed approach. But you are no longer on the instrument approach track, so what do you fly? The rule is to make an initial climbing turn towards the landing runway. That keeps you inside the circling area and over the aerodrome while you gain height. Continue the turn until you are overhead the aerodrome, and then establish yourself on the missed approach track for the instrument approach you flew. Note that carefully: it is the missed approach for the approach you came in on, not for the runway you were circling to. Tell air traffic control as soon as the aircraft is safely climbing.
Take-off
Take-off minima: can I see enough, and can I come back? Visibility or RVR A minimum RVR or visibility is published for each runway. It must give enough guidance to keep the aircraft straight, and to stop or continue after an engine failure.
Runway facilities Lower minima are allowed with centre line and edge lights and multiple RVR reports; higher without them.
Take-off alternate If the weather is below landing minima at the departure aerodrome, you need a take-off alternate within a set flying time.
Obstacles Take-off minima assume you can see and avoid close-in obstacles, or that you follow the published departure and climb gradient.
Your own limits The minima on the chart are the lowest permitted . Operator and personal minima may be higher.
Brief the departure First turn, first altitude, engine failure plan, and the route back to an approach.
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now the minima. For take off, the question is: can I see enough to keep the aircraft straight on the runway, and to stop or continue safely if an engine fails? So a minimum runway visual range or visibility is published for each runway. It is lower where the runway has centre line and edge lighting, and higher where it does not. There is a second question: can I come back? If the weather at the departure aerodrome is below the landing minima, you could not return after a problem, so you need a take off alternate within a set flying time. And remember that the published figures are the lowest permitted. Your operator, and your own good sense, may set higher ones.
Visibility
Runway visual range is what the pilot can see along the runway Meteorological visibility : how far an observer can see, in the reported directionRVR : the distance over which the pilot on the centre line can see the runway lights or markings Measured by instruments beside the runway at the touchdown zone, mid-point and stop end The touchdown zone value is normally the controlling one for landing RVR depends on the light intensity : it can be higher than the reported visibility at night When no RVR is reported, the visibility may be converted using published factors N
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Two different measures of visibility are used. Meteorological visibility is how far a weather observer can see. Runway visual range, or R V R, is something more specific: the distance over which a pilot on the centre line can see the runway lights or markings. It is measured by instruments beside the runway, at up to three positions: the touchdown zone, the mid point and the stop end. For landing, the touchdown zone value is normally the controlling one. Because R V R depends on the brightness of the lights, it can be higher than the reported visibility, especially at night. And where no R V R is reported, the visibility may be converted to an equivalent value using published factors.
Landing minima
The approach ban: when you may not continue Landing minima are a DA or MDA together with a minimum RVR or visibility An approach may be started whatever the reported RVR But it may not be continued below 1,000 ft above the aerodrome (or past the outer marker or equivalent) if the reported RVR is below the minimum If the RVR falls below the minimum after you have passed that point, you may continue to the DA or MDA At the DA or MDA the final test is always the same: do I have the required visual reference? Cloud base is not normally a ban, but it tells you what to expect RVR checked Below 1,000 ft: committed to continue N
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Landing minima have two parts: a decision altitude or minimum descent altitude, and a minimum runway visual range or visibility. The rule that links them to the approach is called the approach ban. You may start an approach whatever the reported R V R. But you may not continue below one thousand feet above the aerodrome, or past the outer marker or an equivalent position, if the reported R V R is below your minimum. If the R V R falls below the minimum after you have passed that point, you may continue down to the decision altitude or minimum descent altitude. And there, the final test is always the same: do I have the required visual reference, or not?
What you must see
The required visual references To descend below the DA or MDA, at least one of these must be distinctly visible and identifiable , and the aircraft must be in a position to land normally:
Approach lights Elements of the approach lighting system. On their own, usually not enough to go below 100 ft above the touchdown zone.
Threshold The threshold itself, its markings , its lights or the threshold identification lights.
Glide slope indicator The PAPI or other visual approach slope indicator.
Touchdown zone The touchdown zone, its markings or its lights .
Runway edge lights The lights along the sides of the runway.
Runway markings Centre line, aiming point and side-stripe markings.
Not enough A glow in the fog, the ground straight down, or a single light. You need to identify what you see.
Then Keep it in sight. Lose it below the minima → go around.
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
10
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
So what exactly must you see? To descend below the decision altitude or the minimum descent altitude, at least one of the following must be distinctly visible and identifiable. Elements of the approach lighting system. The threshold, its markings, or its lights. The visual glide slope indicator, such as the P A P I. The touchdown zone, its markings or its lights. Or the runway edge lights or runway markings. A glow in the fog, a glimpse of the ground straight down, or a single unidentified light is not enough. You must be able to identify what you are looking at, and the aircraft must be in a position to land normally. And if you lose that reference after going below the minima, you go around.
Summary
What to carry into the cockpit and the exam Circling Visual manoeuvre at or above circling MDA, runway in sight, inside the area for your category.
Radius A 1.68, B 2.66, C 4.20, D 5.28 NM from each threshold.
Sight lost Climbing turn towards the landing runway, then the missed approach of the approach flown.
Take-off Minimum RVR for directional control; take-off alternate if you cannot return.
Approach ban No descent below 1,000 ft above the aerodrome with RVR below minima.
References Approach lights, threshold, PAPI, touchdown zone, runway lights or markings: identified.
Chapter 12 · Circling and Minima
11
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To sum up the lesson, and the course. Circling is a visual manoeuvre, flown at or above the circling minimum, with the runway in sight, inside the protected area for your category. If you lose sight, make a climbing turn towards the landing runway and fly the missed approach of the approach you flew. For take off you need the minimum R V R, and an alternate if you could not return. You may not continue below one thousand feet above the aerodrome with the R V R below minima. And at the minima you must see and identify the required visual references. Brief every approach, fly it by numbers, and never hesitate to go around.