Principles of Flight · Chapter 23
Asymmetric Thrust What happens when an engine fails on a multi-engine aeroplane, why there is a minimum control speed, and how to fly and climb safely on the remaining engine.
thrust drag yaw towards the dead engine © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Welcome to asymmetric thrust, the most important handling lesson for anyone who will fly a multi-engine aeroplane. When one engine fails, the aircraft does not simply lose half its power. It yaws hard towards the dead engine, it rolls, its climb performance collapses, and below a certain speed the pilot cannot hold it straight at all. In this lesson we find out exactly why, what decides that minimum control speed, how to fly with one engine out, and how to keep climbing safely.
Roadmap
One engine out: control first, then performance Failure Moments VMC Control speeds Performance The failure Yaw towards the dead engine, then roll. Stop the yaw.
The moments Thrust × arm, drag × arm against rudder force × arm. The critical engine .
Control speeds VMCA, VMCG, VMCL : definitions and what moves them.
Performance Half the thrust, ~80% less climb. VXSE, VYSE and drag reduction.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
This lesson follows the order in which things happen when an engine fails on a twin. First the failure itself: the aircraft yaws towards the dead engine and then rolls, and the pilot must stop the yaw. Second, the moments: the live engine and the dead engine together make a yawing moment, the rudder makes an opposing moment, and the propeller layout decides which engine is the critical one. Third, the minimum control speeds: V M C A in the air, V M C G on the ground and V M C L on the approach, how they are defined for certification and what makes them higher or lower. Finally, performance: losing half the thrust takes away about eighty per cent of the climb, so we look at the best single-engine speeds and how to cut drag. Control always comes first; performance second.
Engine failure
Yaw, roll, and the vital action Thrust falls and drag rises on the failed side Immediate yaw towards the dead engine , then roll the same way The nose drops and the airspeed decays Vital action: STOP THE YAW with rudder Then hold the wings with aileron and keep the speed thrust (live) drag (dead) Yaw towards the dead engine 1 Yaw towards the dead engine 2 Roll the same way 3 Nose drops, speed decays Vital action: STOP THE YAW
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
When an engine fails on a multi-engine aircraft, thrust on that side disappears and, worse, the dead engine now makes drag. Three things follow. The airspeed starts to decay, the nose tends to drop, and most significantly there is an immediate yawing moment towards the dead engine. Watch the aircraft. The left engine has failed, the live right engine is still pulling and the dead left engine is dragging, so the nose swings left. As it yaws, the right wing moves faster than the left and makes more lift, so the aircraft rolls left as well. The vital action is to stop the yaw, with rudder on the side of the live engine; here, right rudder. Then the wings are held with aileron and the speed is protected. Everything in this lesson is about how much rudder that takes, and when it is no longer enough.
The moments
Yawing moment against rudder moment T (live engine) D (dead engine) thrust arm drag arm rudder force rudder arm yawing moment rudder moment Yawing moment = T × thrust arm + D × drag arm Rudder moment = rudder force × rudder arm rudder force ∝ deflection × IAS² Bigger yaw: more thrust, engine further out, more drag (windmilling prop) Less rudder: low IAS, aft CG (short arm)
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Let us look from above at the moments. The yawing moment is the thrust of the live engine multiplied by its thrust arm, the distance from the centre of gravity to its thrust line, plus the drag of the dead engine multiplied by its arm. So it is bigger when the live engine is giving more thrust, which depends on the throttle setting and the density altitude, when the engines are mounted further out, and when the dead engine makes more drag. Against it the pilot has the rudder moment: the side force on the fin and rudder multiplied by the rudder arm, the distance from the centre of gravity to the fin. The rudder force depends on how far the rudder is deflected and on the dynamic pressure, in other words the indicated airspeed. So the pilot's ability to stop the yaw depends on rudder deflection, CG position, which sets the arm, and above all the indicated airspeed.
Minimum control speed
Below VMC, full rudder is not enough Full rudder moment grows with IAS² ; the engine yawing moment does not VMC : the lowest IAS at which full rudder still balances the yawLess thrust (altitude, heat) → lower VMC : 80% thrust → VMC × √0.8 Example: 90 kt at sea level → about 80.5 kt with 20% less thrust Shorter rudder arm (aft CG, 10% shorter) → 90 ÷ √0.9 ≈ 95 kt IAS (kt) → yawing moment 60 80 100 120 140 full rudder moment ∝ IAS² engine yaw, sea level VMC 90 at altitude (thrust −20%) VMC 80 Below VMC, full rudder cannot balance the yaw
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now picture the worst case. Full rudder is applied, the CG is at the aft limit so the rudder arm is shortest, and the indicated airspeed is just enough for the rudder moment to equal the yawing moment. The aircraft is balanced on a knife edge. Any further loss of speed and the rudder moment, which goes with airspeed squared, falls below the engine's yawing moment, and the aircraft yaws uncontrollably towards the dead engine. That threshold speed is V M C, the minimum control speed. Because the rudder moment goes with speed squared, V M C goes with the square root of the yawing moment. Suppose V M C is ninety knots at sea level. Higher up, if the live engine gives twenty per cent less thrust, V M C falls by the square root of nought point eight, to about eighty and a half knots. Make the rudder arm ten per cent shorter and V M C rises to about ninety-five knots.
Loss of control
Below VMC: yaw, roll and spiral dive Below VMC the yaw towards the dead engine cannot be stopped The yaw makes the outer wing faster: roll towards the dead engine The aircraft enters a spiral dive that flight controls alone cannot stop Near the ground the only cure: close the live throttle(s) That removes the yaw; the aircraft is then force-landed under control IAS falls below VMC yaw grows roll and spiral dive Near the ground, the ONLY way back to control: close the throttle(s) of the live engine(s) removes the yaw · land ahead under control
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
What happens below V M C? Even with full rudder, the yaw towards the dead engine cannot be stopped. As the aircraft yaws, the wing on the live side moves forward and faster, and makes more lift, so the aircraft rolls towards the dead engine too. Watch it: the yaw grows, the roll steepens, and it enters a spiral dive that cannot be stopped with the flight controls alone. Close to the ground this is fatal. In those extreme circumstances there is only one way to regain control: close the throttle, or throttles, of the live engine or engines. That removes the asymmetric thrust and with it the yawing moment, and the aircraft can then be force-landed under control. It is a hard decision to make, which is why you must never let the speed fall below V M C with asymmetric power.
The critical engine
Which engine is critical, and why Left engine fails live right engine: LONG thrust arm → critical Right engine fails live left engine: SHORT thrust arm Both propellers clockwise seen from behind · positive α: down-going blade (right side) gives more thrust Critical engine : the one whose failure gives the biggest yawing moment . With clockwise propellers it is the left : its own thrust line is nearest the centreline.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
One factor in the yawing moment is the thrust arm of the live engine. On a propeller aircraft at a positive angle of attack, the down-going blade meets the air at a bigger angle than the up-going blade and makes more thrust; this is asymmetric blade effect, or P factor. With propellers turning clockwise as seen from behind, the down-going blade is on the right, so each engine's thrust line is displaced to the right of its centre line. Now compare the two failures. If the left engine fails, the live right engine's thrust line is pushed further out, on a long arm, giving the bigger yawing moment and a higher V M C. If the right engine fails, the live left engine's thrust line is shifted in towards the fuselage. So the critical engine, the one whose failure gives the biggest yawing moment, is the left. Notice that it is the engine whose own thrust line is closest to the centreline.
Propeller layouts
Co-rotating, counter-rotating and contra-rotating Designers can remove the critical engine by choosing the direction of rotation.
Co-rotating Both propellers turn the same way (usually clockwise from behind). The left engine is critical. Common on larger turboprops.
Counter-rotating Left turns clockwise , right anticlockwise : both thrust lines shift inboard , P factor and torque balance. No critical engine.
Contra-rotating Two propellers on the same shaft , turning opposite ways, usually driven by one engine. No asymmetric blade effect.
Jets and four engines No P factor or prop torque. On a four-engine aircraft the critical engine is either outboard engine.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Designers have a few options. On co-rotating aircraft, both propellers turn the same way, usually clockwise from behind, and the left engine is critical, as we have just seen. Many larger turboprops are built this way. Small twins often use counter-rotating propellers: the left turns clockwise and the right anticlockwise, so the down-going blades are both on the inboard side, both thrust lines move inboard, the asymmetric blade effects and the torque reactions balance, and there is no longer a critical engine. Do not confuse this with contra-rotating propellers, which are two propellers mounted on the same shaft and turning in opposite directions, usually driven by one engine. Jets have no propeller effects at all. On a four-engine aircraft, the critical engine is either outboard engine, because losing one leaves the other outboard engine pulling on the longest arm.
Balancing the forces 1
Rudder and wings level: balanced moments, sideslip Rudder balances the moments , but its side force is unbalanced Wings level: the aircraft sideslips towards the dead engine Sideslip puts a side force on the keel and fin that balances the rudder force Slip indicator centred , yet the aircraft is sideslipping Drawbacks: big parasite drag , poor climb, risk of fin stall Fine for initial control in the cruise; strong visual references airflow from the left: sideslip rudder sideslip force ball centred Wings level, nose yawed to the live side
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Rudder stops the yaw by balancing the moments, but look at the forces. The rudder makes a side force that nothing else is balancing yet, and there are two ways to balance it. The first is to keep the wings level with aileron. The aircraft then settles with its nose yawed slightly towards the live engine and it sideslips towards the dead engine, so the relative airflow comes from the dead engine side. That sideslip puts a side force on the fuselage and fin, the keel surfaces behind the CG, which balances the rudder force. The turn needle and the slip ball are both central, which is the one case where a centred ball does not mean balanced flight. The advantage is the strong visual horizon references. The disadvantages: the sideslip creates a lot of parasite drag and spoils the climb, and if the sideslip angle is large the fin could stall. It is acceptable for initial control after a failure in the cruise.
Balancing the forces 2
Bank up to 5° towards the live engine Bank towards the live engine: a side component of lift balances the rudder force No sideslip , so minimum drag and the best climb Less side force on the fin: more rudder authority , lower VMC Bank limited to 5° to keep enough vertical lift Indication: turn needle central, ball ½ diameter towards the live engine The preferred method after take-off or go-around lift weight side component of lift rudder side force Left engine dead · bank 5° towards the live (right) engine ball ½ diameter to the live side No sideslip minimum drag best climb
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
10
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The better method is to bank slightly towards the live engine. Tilting the lift gives it a small sideways component, which balances the rudder side force, so the aircraft no longer needs to sideslip. Watch the aircraft roll a few degrees towards the live engine, here to the right. With no sideslip the drag is at its minimum and the climb at its best. There is a bonus: without sideslip, the fin no longer has to fight the sideslip force, so the rudder has more authority and V M C is lower. The bank must not exceed five degrees, or too much vertical lift is lost. The cockpit indications are worth learning: the turn needle is central, but the ball sits about half a diameter towards the live engine. The ball is not centred, yet the aircraft is not sideslipping. This is the preferred method for critical moments such as an engine failure just after take-off or during a go-around.
The two methods
Wings level versus 5° bank towards the live engine Wings level Up to 5° bank to the live engine Side force from rudder balanced by Sideslip force on the keel and fin Side component of lift Sideslip Yes, towards the dead engine None Drag and climb High drag, reduced climb Minimum drag, best climb Rudder needed / VMC More rudder; fin may stall Less rudder; lower VMC Turn needle / ball Both central Needle central, ball ½ diameter to live side Advantage Strong visual horizon references Most efficient: use after take-off and go-around
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
11
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here are the two methods side by side. With the wings level, the rudder side force is balanced by the sideslip force on the keel surfaces; with up to five degrees of bank towards the live engine, it is balanced by a side component of lift. So the first sideslips towards the dead engine, and the second does not. That difference drives everything else. Sideslip means high drag and a reduced climb, more rudder and possibly a stalled fin, while the banked method gives minimum drag, the best climb and a lower V M C. On the instruments, the wings-level method shows both needle and ball central; the banked method shows the needle central and the ball half a diameter towards the live engine. The wings-level method is easier to fly visually, but when climb performance matters, after take-off or during a go-around, bank towards the live engine.
Dead-engine drag
Windmilling, stationary and feathered propellers Drag from the dead engine always adds to the yawing moment Windmilling : driven by the airflow; highest drag (and torque)Stationary : drag but no torque; less than windmillingFeathered : blades edge-on; least drag , no rotationClosing the dead engine's cowl flap also cuts drag Absent on jets blade angle → drag of the dead engine 0° 15° 30° 45° 60° 90° windmilling at fine pitch: HIGH drag stationary: less drag feathered: LEAST drag schematic: drag falls as the blade turns edge-on
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
12
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The dead engine adds to the yawing moment through its drag, and the amount depends on what its propeller is doing. A windmilling propeller, held at fine pitch and driven round by the airflow like a windmill, produces a lot of drag, because the airflow is doing work turning the engine over. That is the worst case. If the propeller is stopped, it still makes drag, but less than when it windmills, and there is no torque. A feathered propeller, with its blades turned edge-on to the airflow, makes the least drag of all. So one of the first actions after identifying a failed engine on a piston or turboprop twin is to feather its propeller. Closing the cowl flap on the dead engine reduces drag a little more. Of course, on a jet there is no propeller, so this effect is absent.
Rolling moments
Why the aircraft also rolls Counter-rotating propellers cancel torque and blade effect; jets have none of these propeller effects.
Slipstream: less lift behind the dead engine dead live Torque reaction of the live engine dead live roll left Sideslip + dihedral helps a little dead live Slipstream lift The dead side loses slipstream over the wing, so less lift there: a roll towards the dead engine , worse with flap down.
Torque reaction Clockwise props try to roll the aircraft left . Losing the left engine leaves the right engine's torque: biggest roll to the left.
Asymmetric blade effect Clockwise props: the right engine has the longer thrust arm, so the left failure gives more yaw.
Sideslip and dihedral Sideslipping towards the dead engine, dihedral raises that wing's lift and offsets some of the slipstream loss.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
13
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Engine failure also brings rolling moments. First, slipstream: a propeller blows fast air over the wing behind it, adding lift. When an engine fails, that wing loses its slipstream lift, so total lift falls and, more importantly, the aircraft rolls towards the dead engine. With trailing edge flap down the effect is bigger, because the flapped wing is working at a higher lift coefficient. Second, torque reaction. With propellers turning clockwise from behind, each engine tries to roll the aircraft to the left. Lose the left engine and the right engine's torque is still rolling the aircraft left, the same way as the yaw, so the left engine failure gives the biggest rolling moment. Third, asymmetric blade effect, which we have met. Fourth, sideslip: if the aircraft sideslips towards the dead engine, dihedral increases the lift on that wing and recovers some of the loss. Counter-rotating propellers cancel the torque and blade effects.
CG, weight and airspeed
Rudder arm, fin masking and dynamic pressure The aircraft rotates about the CG ; CG position does not change the engine yaw, only the rudder arm Aft CG = shortest rudder arm = worst caseMore weight → higher α → more P factor, and more fin masking by wing and fuselage wake Control power depends on dynamic pressure : measured best by CAS IAS is the vital element of asymmetric controlrudder arm Forward CG: long rudder arm rudder arm Aft CG (worst case): short rudder arm The engine yawing moment is unchanged; only the rudder arm changes
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
14
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Three more factors. The CG: the aircraft rotates about its centre of gravity, so moving the CG fore and aft hardly changes the engine's yawing moment, but it does change the rudder arm. With the CG on the aft limit the rudder arm is shortest and the pilot has the least ability to oppose the yaw, so that is the worst case. Weight: a heavier aircraft flies at a higher angle of attack at any given speed. That increases the asymmetric blade effect, so the yawing moment is bigger, and it means more of the fin and rudder sit in the disturbed wake of the wing and fuselage, so the rudder is less effective. Airspeed: with full deflection, control power depends on dynamic pressure, which at low speed is best measured by the calibrated airspeed, the indicated airspeed corrected for position error. A higher speed means a bigger rudder moment. The indicated airspeed is the vital element in controlling asymmetric thrust.
Certification
VMCA: minimum control speed in the air VMCA is the CAS at which, when the critical engine is suddenly made inoperative, control can be maintained and straight flight held with no more than 5° of bank .
Condition for establishing VMCA Why it is the worst case Maximum available take-off power/thrust on the live engine(s)Biggest yawing moment Most unfavourable CG (normally aft) and trimmed for take-offShortest rudder arm Maximum sea-level take-off weight Low density altitude, full thrust Most critical take-off configuration, gear up , out of ground effect Airborne case Dead propeller windmilling , or feathered if auto-feather is fitted Most drag on the dead side Rudder force ≤ 150 lb ; no reduction of power on the live engine(s) A normal pilot can hold it VMCA may not exceed 1.13 VSR Keeps VMCA close to the stall
VMCA is about directional control only : there is no climb requirement. At VMCA a light-twin pilot can expect to hold heading , not height.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
15
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Certification authorities define the minimum control speeds under worst-case conditions, with a margin built in for pilot reaction and an ageing aircraft. V M C A, the airborne minimum control speed, is the calibrated airspeed at which, when the critical engine is suddenly made inoperative, the pilot can keep control and maintain straight flight with no more than five degrees of bank. It is established with maximum take-off power on the live engines, the CG in its most unfavourable position, normally aft, trimmed for take-off, at maximum sea-level take-off weight, in the most critical take-off configuration but with the gear up and clear of ground effect, and with the dead propeller windmilling, or feathered if there is automatic feathering. The rudder force must not exceed one hundred and fifty pounds, and the pilot must not need to reduce power on the live engines. V M C A may not exceed one point one three times the reference stalling speed. And note: it is about control only, with no performance requirement.
What moves VMCA
Factors affecting VMCA Factor Effect VMCA Bank towards the live engine (up to 5°)Less rudder needed Lower CG aft Shorter rudder arm Higher Higher altitude or temperature Less thrust, smaller yawing moment Lower Low IAS: aileron effectiveness Big down-aileron adds drag and may stall that wing Must be high enough to prevent it Take-off flap More slipstream lift difference, more aileron needed Indirectly higher Gear down Keel area ahead of CG: less directional stability Slightly higher Windmilling prop (vs feathered)More drag on the dead side Higher
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
16
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Banking up to five degrees towards the live engine reduces the rudder needed, so V M C A is lower. An aft CG shortens the rudder arm, so V M C A is higher. Higher altitude or temperature reduces the thrust of an unsupercharged engine, so the yawing moment is smaller and V M C A is lower. At low airspeed the ailerons are weak and need large deflections. The down-going aileron on the dead engine side adds drag, which adds to the yaw, and at a high lift coefficient it could even stall that wing and roll the aircraft towards the dead engine; V M C A must be high enough to prevent that. Flap does not change V M C A directly, but take-off flap increases the slipstream lift difference, needs more aileron, and so indirectly raises it. Gear down adds keel area ahead of the CG and raises it slightly. A windmilling propeller raises it too.
Stall or loss of control?
VS and VMCA change differently with altitude VS (as IAS) is roughly constant at these altitudes VMCA falls with altitude as thrust falls Typically they coincide around 3 000 ft Above that, slowing with full power on the live engine reaches the stall first A stall with asymmetric power can lead straight to a spin IAS (kt) → pressure altitude (ft) 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 2000 4000 6000 8000 VS (IAS) VMCA coincide ≈ 3 000 ft above: stall comes first below: loss of control first
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
17
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Stalling speed, as an indicated airspeed, stays roughly constant at the low altitudes we are considering, so on this graph it is a vertical line. V M C A, on the other hand, falls with altitude, because the live engine produces less thrust in thinner air. Typically the two lines cross at around three thousand feet. Below that altitude, if the speed decays with full power on the live engine, you reach V M C A and lose directional control before the stall. Above it, the stall arrives first. That might sound better, but a stall with full asymmetric power is very dangerous, because the yaw at the stall can turn it into a spin. Either way the margin you have before losing control is reduced, which is why the speed must be watched closely whenever one engine is out.
On the ground
VMCG: control on the take-off run CAS on the take-off run at which, after sudden failure of the critical engine, control is kept with primary aerodynamic controls only No nose-wheel steering : on wet or icy runways it hydroplanes from about 70–90 ktLateral deviation from the centreline ≤ 30 ft (9.1 m) ; rudder force ≤ 150 lb Max take-off thrust, trimmed for take-off, worst CG, max sea-level weight On the ground the aircraft pivots on the main gear: shorter rudder arm , so VMCG is usually higher than VMCA Higher altitude or temperature → lower VMCG ≤ 30 ft (9.1 m) engine fails recovered parallel primary controls only (no nose-wheel steering) rudder force ≤ 150 lb ailerons only to keep wings level on the ground the aircraft pivots on the main wheels: shorter rudder arm
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
18
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
V M C G, the minimum control speed on the ground, is the calibrated airspeed during the take-off run at which, when the critical engine suddenly fails, the pilot can keep control using the primary aerodynamic controls alone, and continue the take-off safely with normal skill. Nose-wheel steering may not be used, because on a wet, icy or slippery runway the nose wheel can hydroplane from about seventy to ninety knots. Using it would give a falsely low figure. The aircraft's path must not deviate more than thirty feet, about nine metres, from the centreline before it is brought back parallel; the rudder force may not exceed a hundred and fifty pounds, and aileron may be used only to keep the wings level. On the ground the aircraft pivots about the main wheels, behind the CG, so the rudder arm is shorter, and V M C G is usually higher than V M C A. Like V M C A, it falls with altitude and temperature.
On the approach
VMCL: control in the landing configuration CAS on the approach, all engines operating, at which sudden failure of the critical engine can be controlled with ≤ 5° bank Most critical approach configuration, go-around power on the live engine(s) Prop of the dead engine in the position it takes without pilot action Rudder force ≤ 150 lb; no exceptional skill or strength Roll requirement : 20° bank away from the dead engine in ≤ 5 s Approach, all engines → critical engine fails wings level 20° away from the dead engine ≤ 5 s · Go-around power on the live engine(s) · Most critical approach/landing configuration · Most unfavourable CG and weight · Rudder force ≤ 150 lb, bank ≤ 5° straight flight · Roll requirement: aileron effectiveness matters
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
19
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
V M C L applies on the approach. It is the calibrated airspeed, during approach and landing with all engines operating, at which the pilot can control the aircraft after the critical engine suddenly fails, and fly straight with no more than five degrees of bank. It is set with the aircraft in its most critical approach and landing configuration, the most unfavourable CG and weight, trimmed for the approach, with go-around power on the live engines and the dead propeller in whatever position it reaches without pilot action. The rudder force must not exceed one hundred and fifty pounds, and the aircraft must not need exceptional skill or strength. What makes V M C L different is the roll requirement: the ailerons must be able to roll the aircraft through twenty degrees, away from the dead engine, in not more than five seconds. So aileron effectiveness at low speed, and the extra drag of the down-going aileron, matter especially here.
Summary of control speeds
VMCA, VMCG and VMCL compared VMCA VMCG VMCL Phase Airborne, take-off configuration (gear up) Take-off run on the ground Approach and landing Engine failure Critical engine, sudden Critical engine, sudden Critical engine, sudden, from all-engines approach Power on live engine(s) Max take-off Max take-off Go-around Control limits ≤ 5° bank, ≤ 150 lb rudder ≤ 30 ft deviation, no nose-wheel steering ≤ 5° bank; roll 20° in ≤ 5 s Special point ≤ 1.13 VSR; no climb requirement Usually higher than VMCA Includes a roll requirement Altitude / temperature ↑ Lower Lower Lower
All three are worst-case CAS figures in the flight manual. Thrust falls with density altitude, so every VMC decreases as altitude and temperature rise.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
20
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
V M C A is for the airborne aircraft in the take-off configuration with the gear up; V M C G for the take-off run on the ground; V M C L for the approach and landing. V M C A and V M C G use maximum take-off power on the live engines, V M C L uses go-around power. The control limits differ: five degrees of bank and a hundred and fifty pounds of rudder force in the air, thirty feet of deviation without nose-wheel steering on the ground, and for V M C L a roll requirement of twenty degrees in five seconds. V M C A may not exceed one point one three V S R and has no climb requirement, and V M C G is usually higher than V M C A. Finally, since all of them depend on the thrust of the live engine, every one of them decreases as altitude and temperature increase.
Performance on one engine
Half the thrust, about 80% less climb Thrust (angle of climb) drag two engines one engine VX VXSE excess thrust −80% Power (rate of climb) power required two engines one engine VYSE excess power −79% Losing one of two engines halves the thrust, but drag is unchanged, so the excess thrust and power fall by about 80% . Angle: VXSE . Rate: VYSE .
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
21
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now performance. Climb depends on excess thrust for the angle and excess power for the rate. When a twin loses an engine, total thrust halves, but the drag is unchanged, in fact slightly more, so the excess thrust falls by far more than half. In this model it falls by about eighty per cent, and the excess power by about the same. Remember the jet example from the climb lesson: ninety kilonewtons of thrust and thirty-five of drag gave an excess of fifty-five; with one engine, forty-five minus thirty-five leaves only ten. The best angle of climb on one engine comes at V X S E, where the gap between one-engine thrust and drag is greatest, a little faster than V X with both engines but still a safe margin above the stall. The best rate comes at V Y S E, where the excess power is greatest. Every extra bit of drag, from sideslip, flap, gear or a turn, eats directly into this tiny margin.
Single-engine speeds
VXSE, VYSE and the blue line VXSE : best single-engine angle of climb (max excess thrust)VYSE : best single-engine rate of climb (max excess power)VY and VYSE are faster than VX and VXSE: bigger margin above stall and VMCA Under most circumstances fly VYSE On light twins VYSE is the blue radial line on the ASI; VMC is a red radial line 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 KNOTS Light twin ASI: red radial = VMC, blue radial = VYSE VMC VYSE
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
22
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
On one engine there are two key speeds. V X S E is the best single-engine angle of climb speed, where the excess thrust is greatest. V Y S E is the best single-engine rate of climb speed, where the excess power is greatest. V Y and V Y S E are faster than V X and V X S E, so they give a safer margin above both the stall and V M C A, and under most circumstances V Y S E is the speed to fly. It is so important on small twins that it is marked on the airspeed indicator with a blue radial line, and pilots call it blue line speed. V M C is marked with a red radial line. The rule many instructors teach is simple: after an engine failure, never let the speed go below the red line, and fly the blue line.
Putting it together
After an engine failure: control, then drag Control Stop the yaw with rudder; hold the speed above VMC . Below it, close the live throttle.
Feather Feather the dead propeller; close its cowl flap .
Clean up Gear up ; raise the flap carefully , in stages.
Bank Up to 5° towards the live engine : no sideslip, least drag.
Speed and power VYSE (blue line) with maximum continuous power on the live engine.
No turns Avoid turning until well clear of the ground : a turn adds drag and needs more lift.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
23
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
So what does the pilot actually do? First, control: stop the yaw with rudder and keep the speed above V M C; if it does fall below and control is going, close the live throttle. Then attack the drag, because every bit of drag comes straight out of a tiny climb margin. Feather the dead propeller and close its cowl flap. Raise the landing gear. Raise the flap carefully, in stages, because flap was giving lift as well as drag. Bank up to five degrees towards the live engine so there is no sideslip. Fly V Y S E, blue line speed, with maximum continuous power on the live engine, which gives the best climb and good control. And avoid turns until you are well away from the ground: a turn needs more lift, which brings more induced drag, and the control deflections needed to fly asymmetrically are already adding drag of their own.
Summary
What to take into the exam Failure Yaw towards the dead engine, then roll; nose drops, speed decays. Stop the yaw.
Moments T × arm + D × arm vs rudder force × arm. Rudder force ∝ deflection × IAS².
Critical engine Failure gives the biggest yaw : left, with clockwise props. Its thrust line is nearest the centreline.
Balancing Wings level: sideslip, ball centred. ≤ 5° bank to live engine : no slip, ball ½ to live side.
VMCA ≤ 5° bank, ≤ 150 lb, ≤ 1.13 VSR, aft CG, windmilling prop. Heading only, no climb.
VMCG / VMCL VMCG: no nose-wheel steering, ≤ 30 ft, usually > VMCA. VMCL: roll 20° in 5 s.
What lowers VMC Altitude, temperature, bank to live engine, forward CG, feathering. Aft CG, flap, gear raise it.
Performance Excess thrust down ~80%. VXSE angle, VYSE blue line rate.
Chapter 23 · Asymmetric Thrust
24
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To finish. When an engine fails, the aircraft yaws towards the dead engine and rolls, so stop the yaw. The yawing moment is the live engine's thrust times its arm plus the dead engine's drag times its arm; the rudder moment is the rudder force times the rudder arm, and the rudder force depends on airspeed squared, which is why there is a minimum control speed. The critical engine is the one whose failure gives the biggest yaw, the left engine with clockwise propellers. You can fly wings level, with sideslip and a centred ball, or better with up to five degrees of bank towards the live engine, no sideslip, and the ball half a diameter to the live side. V M C A, V M C G and V M C L are worst-case figures, and all of them fall with altitude and temperature. On one engine the climb falls by around eighty per cent, so fly V Y S E, the blue line, and clean the aircraft up.