Principles of Flight · Chapter 19
Flight Controls and Control Forces How the primary controls turn the aeroplane, why they feel heavy at speed, and the balances, tabs and powered systems that keep them light, safe and free of flutter.
tailplane hinge elevator load tab force Hinge moment = F × d © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Chapter nineteen is about the flying controls and the forces a pilot feels through them. We start with the primary controls and the axis each one works about. Then we look at the hinge moment, the reason controls get heavy as speed rises, and all the clever ways designers lighten them: inset hinges, horns, internal balance, tabs of four kinds, and powered controls with artificial feel. We finish with mass balance against flutter, and with how the elevator and tailplane hold the aeroplane in pitch.
Roadmap
Flying the controls, and feeling them Four parts: what the controls do, why they get heavy, how designers lighten them, and how they stay safe.
1 · The controls Elevator, ailerons, rudder; elevons, ruddervators, tailerons; camber, incidence and spoiling.
2 · Hinge moments Air load × arm = hinge moment = stick force. Grows with deflection and IAS².
3 · Lightening Inset hinge, horn, internal balance; balance, anti-balance, servo and spring tabs; powered controls and Q feel.
4 · Safe in pitch Mass balance and flutter; elevator action; tailplane loads with speed and g; tail icing.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
This lesson is about the flying controls, and about the forces you feel when you move them. We will go in four parts. First, the controls themselves: which surface turns the aeroplane about which axis, the combined surfaces found on some designs, and the three ways a control can change an aerodynamic force. Second, the hinge moment, which is the real reason a control feels heavy, and why that heaviness rises so steeply with speed. Third, the many ways designers make big, fast aeroplanes controllable by a human arm: aerodynamic balances, four kinds of tab, and hydraulic power with artificial feel. Finally, we make the controls safe: mass balance against flutter, and how the elevator and tailplane hold the aeroplane in pitch through the whole speed range, including the danger of ice on the tail.
Part 1 · The primary controls
Three controls, three axes Controls are flap-type surfaces at the extremities: the longest arm about the CG Elevator : pitch about the lateral axis (longitudinal control)Ailerons : roll about the longitudinal axis (lateral control); spoilers may help or replace themRudder : yaw about the normal axis (directional control)Stick back: elevator up . Wheel left: left aileron up , right down. Left pedal: rudder left Longitudinal axis: roll (ailerons) Lateral axis: pitch (elevator) Normal axis through the CG, out of the page: yaw (rudder) ailerons elevators rudder
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Every aeroplane has a control system so that the pilot can manoeuvre and trim it about each of its three axes. The controls are flap-type surfaces placed as far from the centre of gravity as possible, at the tail and near the wingtips, so that a modest force gives a large moment. The elevator controls pitch about the lateral axis; we call that longitudinal control. The ailerons control roll about the longitudinal axis, called lateral control, and on many jets spoilers help them or even replace them. The rudder controls yaw about the normal axis, which is directional control. Notice the crossed names: longitudinal control works about the lateral axis. Now the senses. Pull back and the elevator rises, pitching the nose up. Turn the wheel left and the left aileron goes up, the right one down. Push the left pedal and the rudder swings left.
Part 1 · Two jobs, one surface
Elevons, ruddervators and tailerons Some designs let one set of surfaces do the work of two controls. The trick is always the same: move together for one job, move differentially for the other.
Elevons Elevator + aileron on a tailless (often delta) wing. Together : pitch. Opposite : roll.
Ruddervators Rudder + elevator on a V (butterfly) tail . Together : pitch. Opposite : yaw.
Tailerons Two slab tailplane halves. Together : pitch. Independently : roll.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Some aircraft combine two controls in a single set of surfaces. An elevon does the job of both elevator and aileron. You find elevons on tailless designs, such as many delta-wing aircraft, which have no conventional tailplane: move both elevons up together and the nose rises; move one up and one down and the aircraft rolls. A ruddervator belongs to a V tail, sometimes called a butterfly tail, where two slanted surfaces replace the separate fin and tailplane. Moving both ruddervators the same way gives pitch, and moving them in opposite senses gives yaw. Tailerons are the two halves of an all-moving slab tailplane. Together they act as a normal pitch control, and moved independently they add roll control, which is common on fighters. The exam favourite is the definition of an elevon: a combined aileron and elevator on an aircraft without a conventional tailplane.
Part 1 · Making a force
Three ways to change an aerodynamic force Control force ∝ ½ρV² × S × deflection dynamic pressure (set by IAS) · surface area · angle the surface is moved Change the camber A hinged flap-type surface (elevator, aileron, rudder) changes the camber of the wing, tailplane or fin.
Change the incidence An all-moving (slab) tailplane : no elevator, the whole surface pivots to a new incidence.
Spoil the flow Spoilers rise from the upper surface, cutting lift and adding drag; they rise with the up-going aileron.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To turn the aeroplane, a control must change the aerodynamic force on some surface, and there are three ways to do that. The commonest is to change the camber: deflecting a hinged surface such as the elevator, the aileron or the rudder changes the effective camber of the tailplane, wing or fin, and therefore its lift. The second is to change the incidence of the whole surface. That is the all-moving or slab tailplane: there is no separate elevator, and a pitch input rotates the entire tailplane. The third is to spoil the airflow. A spoiler panel rises from the upper surface of the wing, destroying some lift and adding drag, and for roll it rises on the wing with the up-going aileron. Whichever method is used, the size of the force depends on the dynamic pressure, which is set by the indicated airspeed, multiplied by the surface area and by how far the surface is moved.
Part 1 · How a control works
A deflected surface changes camber Deflecting a surface down adds camber : more lift at every angle of attack The whole lift curve shifts up ; the zero-lift angle becomes more negative C L max rises , but the stalling angle falls a littleDeflecting it up does the opposite: the curve shifts down The change of force, far from the CG, gives the turning moment -10° -5° 0° 5° 10° 15° 20° 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 surface 10° down: more camber neutral surface 10° up: less camber Angle of attack α C L dots = C L max
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here is what a control surface actually does to its aerofoil. When the trailing edge surface moves down, the section gains camber. At any given angle of attack it now gives more lift, so the whole lift curve moves upward and the zero-lift angle becomes more negative. The maximum lift coefficient, C L max, increases, but the section stalls at a slightly smaller angle of attack. Remember that last point: an aileron moved down lowers the stalling angle of that part of the wing. Deflect the surface up and you get the opposite: less camber, and the lift curve moves down. Watch the tailplane section on screen. As the elevator goes down the flow speeds up over the top and the lift arrow grows. Because the tailplane, fin and ailerons sit a long way from the centre of gravity, this modest change of force gives a powerful turning moment.
Part 2 · Hinge moments
Control loads grow with IAS squared Air load on a surface ∝ ½ρV² × area × deflection ½ρV² is the dynamic pressure , read as IAS : so load ∝ IAS² Double the IAS : four times the load for the same deflectionHigh speed: small deflections do the job, and the controls feel firm Low speed: large deflections needed; controls feel sloppy near the stall 0 60 120 180 240 300 0 1 2 3 4 10° deflection 5° deflection 1 000 N 4 000 N IAS (knots) Air load on the surface (thousand newtons)
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Before we look at hinge moments, get this relationship firmly in your head. The air load on a control surface is proportional to the dynamic pressure, half rho V squared, multiplied by the area of the surface and by its deflection. Dynamic pressure is exactly what the airspeed indicator measures, so we can say the load is proportional to the indicated airspeed squared. Look at the chart. With ten degrees of deflection, suppose the load is one thousand newtons at one hundred and twenty knots. Double the speed to two hundred and forty knots and the load is four times larger, four thousand newtons. That is why, at high speed, a tiny control movement is enough and the controls feel firm and heavy, while at low speed, approaching the stall, you need large deflections and the controls feel light and sloppy.
Part 2 · Hinge moments
Hinge moment and stick force The air load F acts at the surface's own centre of pressure , a distance d behind the hinge Hinge moment = F × d : it tries to return the surface to neutralThe pilot must overcome and then hold it: that is the stick force , the natural feel It grows with surface size , deflection and IAS² On large, fast aircraft it is too big for a human : balance or power is needed F air load on the surface d hinge tries to blow the surface back to neutral relative airflow Hinge moment = F × d F grows with area × deflection × IAS²
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
When a control surface is deflected, the air load on it acts at the centre of pressure of that surface, some distance behind its hinge line. The load times that distance is the hinge moment, and it always tries to blow the surface back towards neutral. To move the surface and then hold it where you want it, you must overcome and then balance the hinge moment by pushing or pulling on the cockpit control. That push or pull is the stick force, and it is what gives a manual control its natural feel. Because the load depends on the area, the deflection and the indicated airspeed squared, and the arm grows with the chord of the surface, the hinge moment on a big surface at high speed becomes enormous. On large or fast aircraft it would simply be too heavy for a pilot, so some form of help is needed: aerodynamic balance or hydraulic power.
Part 2 · Worked example
Putting numbers on the hinge moment A Plain hinge, 150 kt 1 200 N d = 0.12 m 1 200 × 0.12 = 144 N m B Same surface, 300 kt 4 800 N d = 0.12 m 4 800 × 0.12 = 576 N m C 300 kt, hinge set back 4 800 N d = 0.04 m 4 800 × 0.04 = 192 N m Double the IAS: four times the hinge moment. Set the hinge back to a third of the arm: a third of the hinge moment, with the same control force.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Let us put numbers on it. In case A, an elevator at one hundred and fifty knots carries an air load of one thousand two hundred newtons, acting zero point one two metres behind the hinge. The hinge moment is one thousand two hundred times zero point one two, which is one hundred and forty-four newton metres. In case B we fly the same deflection at three hundred knots. The speed has doubled, so the load is four times larger, four thousand eight hundred newtons, and the hinge moment is five hundred and seventy-six newton metres, four times as heavy. In case C we keep three hundred knots but set the hinge back into the surface, so the arm is only zero point zero four metres. Now the hinge moment is one hundred and ninety-two newton metres, a third of case B, yet the elevator still produces the full four thousand eight hundred newtons. That is the idea behind aerodynamic balance.
Part 3 · Lightening the load
Ways to help the pilot Inset hinge Balance tab Servo tab Powered jack Shift area forward Inset hinge , horn , internal balance : part of the load acts ahead of the hinge.
Add a tab Balance and servo tabs: a small force at a long arm does the work. Spring tab mixes both.
Make it heavier An anti-balance tab adds feel when a control would be too light.
Use hydraulics Power-assisted or fully powered controls, with artificial Q feel .
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
10
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
There are two broad routes to lighter controls. One is aerodynamic balance, which uses the airflow itself to reduce the hinge moment. The simplest forms move some of the surface area ahead of the hinge, so that part of the air load works against the rest: the inset hinge, the horn balance and the internal balance. Another family adds a small tab at the trailing edge, where even a small force has a long arm about the hinge. A balance tab helps the pilot, a servo tab lets the pilot fly the surface through the tab alone, and a spring tab blends the two. The anti-balance tab is the odd one out, because it makes the controls heavier, adding feel where they would be too light. When none of these is enough, the other route is hydraulic power, either assisting the pilot or doing all the work, with artificial feel. Do not confuse aerodynamic balance with mass balance, which is about flutter.
Part 3 · Aerodynamic balance
Inset hinge, and the danger of overbalance Set the hinge back into the surface: some area lies ahead of the hinge The arm d shrinks , so hinge moment and stick force fall Effectiveness is unchanged : same area, same deflection, same forceIf the surface CP ever moved ahead of the hinge : overbalance Overbalance: stick force falls, then reverses . Designers must prevent it Plain hinge at the nose F d Inset hinge: hinge set back F d area ahead of the hinge If F ever moved ahead of the hinge: overbalance, stick force falls, then reverses
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
11
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The inset hinge is the simplest aerodynamic balance. Instead of hinging the surface at its nose, the designer moves the hinge back into the surface, so a strip of it lies ahead of the hinge line. The air load still acts at the same place on the surface, but its arm about the new hinge is shorter, so the hinge moment and the stick force are smaller. Crucially, control effectiveness is not reduced: the surface has the same area and deflection, so it makes the same force and the same turning moment on the aircraft. There is a limit, though. If the hinge were set so far back that the centre of pressure of the surface could move ahead of it, the control would be overbalanced. As the load moved forward the stick force would first fade to nothing and then reverse, and the surface would snatch to full deflection on its own. That is very dangerous, so the designer must make sure it can never happen.
Part 3 · Aerodynamic balance
The horn balance A horn is part of the surface at its outer end extending forward of the hinge line The air load on the horn gives a hinge moment opposite to the main surface Net hinge moment and stick force fall ; effectiveness is kept Same principle as the inset hinge, concentrated at the tip The horn is a handy place to carry the mass balance weight Tailplane seen from above (airflow down the page) elevator fixed tailplane hinge line horn ahead of the hinge Air load on the horn: moment opposite to the main surface smaller net hinge moment · same control effectiveness
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
12
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The horn balance works on the same principle as the inset hinge, but instead of a strip along the whole span, a single horn at the outer end of the control surface sticks out forward of the hinge line, usually into a cut-out in the fixed surface. When the elevator or rudder is deflected, the horn is deflected the opposite way relative to the airflow, so the air load on the horn produces a hinge moment in the opposite direction to the moment on the main part of the surface. The net hinge moment, and so the stick force, is reduced, while the control effectiveness is not. In the exam, a horn balance is described as a projection of the outer edge of the control surface forward of the hinge line. Don't confuse it with a rod carrying a weight: that is a mass balance, although designers often put the mass balance weight inside the horn.
Part 3 · Aerodynamic balance
Internal balance: the hidden panel A balance panel ahead of the hinge sits in a chamber inside the wing , with a flexible seal Surface down : pressure falls above the wing and rises below Those pressures act on the panel: an upward push ahead of the hinge That moment opposes the main hinge moment: lighter stick force Same principle as the inset hinge, but no extra drag − + − low pressure above + high pressure below Internal balance (aileron down) balance panel + flexible seal main load Upward push on the panel AHEAD of the hinge opposes the moment of the main load BEHIND it hidden inside the wing: no extra drag
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
13
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Internal balance uses the same idea as the inset hinge, but the balancing area is hidden inside the wing. A panel extends forward from the hinge into a chamber, and a flexible seal joins its nose to the wing structure, so the chamber is divided into an upper and a lower part. The upper part is vented to the upper surface and the lower part to the lower surface. Suppose the aileron moves down. The pressure above the wing falls and the pressure below rises, and the panel feels both: low pressure on top and high pressure underneath, so it is pushed up. Because that push acts ahead of the hinge, it makes a moment opposite to the moment of the main aileron load behind the hinge, and the overall hinge moment is reduced. Since nothing sticks out into the airflow, this method adds no drag, which is why it is common on airliner ailerons.
Part 3 · Tabs
The balance tab A small tab at the trailing edge, linked to the fixed structure It moves opposite to the control surface, automatically Pilot moves the surface; the surface moves the tab Small tab force at a long arm : much less stick force Price: the tab force opposes the control force, so effectiveness is slightly reduced control force tab force rod from the fixed tailplane Balance tab: elevator down, tab up The pilot moves the surface; the surface moves the tab Tab moves opposite to the surface Stick force: lighter · effectiveness: slightly reduced
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
14
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The balance tab is a small surface at the trailing edge of the main control, linked by a rod to the fixed structure ahead of it. Because of the way the linkage is arranged, whenever the pilot moves the control surface, the tab moves automatically in the opposite direction. So the pilot moves the surface, and the surface moves the tab. When the elevator goes down, its air load pushes up; the tab goes up, and its air load pushes down. The tab force is small, but it acts a long way behind the hinge, so it makes a useful hinge moment that helps the pilot, and the stick force falls. Unlike the inset hinge or the horn, the balance tab costs a little effectiveness, because the tab force acts against the control force. A classic exam question: push the stick forward and the elevator goes down, so its balance tab moves up relative to the elevator.
Part 3 · Tabs
The anti-balance tab Linked like a balance tab, but geared to move the same way as the surface Its force adds to the control force: more effective control But it increases the hinge moment : heavier stick force Purpose: give more feel where a control would be too light or too sensitive Often on all-moving tailplanes of light aircraft control force tab force rod from the fixed tailplane Anti-balance tab: elevator down, tab further down The pilot moves the surface; the surface moves the tab Tab moves the same way to the surface Stick force: heavier · effectiveness: increased
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
15
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The anti-balance tab is built exactly like a balance tab, and it is also moved by the surface, but its linkage makes it move in the same direction as the control surface. If the elevator goes down, the anti-balance tab goes down even further. Its force now adds to the force of the main surface, so the control becomes a little more effective. At the same time it adds to the hinge moment, so the stick force becomes heavier. Why would anyone want that? Because some controls are naturally too light, especially an all-moving slab tailplane, which is pivoted close to its own centre of pressure. Without extra feel, the pilot could easily over-control. The anti-balance tab restores a sensible, progressive feel. For the exam, the purpose of an anti-balance tab is to give more feel to the controls.
Part 3 · Tabs
The servo tab The pilot's linkage drives only the tab ; the surface floats free on its hinge The tab's air load flies the surface the opposite way until it balances Very light forces: used on large older jets such as the Boeing 707 Weakness: poor effectiveness at low IAS , when the tab force is small With gust locks on the surfaces, the cockpit controls still move freely control force tab force pilot's linkage goes to the tab only Servo tab: column forward, tab up, elevator down The elevator floats free on its hinge; the tab flies it Tab moves opposite to the surface Stick force: very light · effectiveness: reduced, worst at low IAS
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
16
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
With a servo tab, the pilot does not move the main surface at all. The control linkage goes straight to the tab, and the main surface is free to float on its hinge. When the pilot pushes forward, the tab moves up; the air load on the tab pushes the trailing edge of the elevator down, and the elevator swings down until the moments about its hinge balance. So the tab flies the surface. Stick forces are very light, which is why large early jets such as the Boeing 707 used servo tabs successfully. The weakness is at low speed: the air load on the tab is small, so the surface responds weakly just when you may need large deflections. There is also a ground-check trap. Because the cockpit control is connected only to the tab, it will move fully and freely even if external locks are still clamped on the control surfaces. A free cockpit control proves only that the tabs are free.
Part 3 · Tabs
The spring tab: best of both A servo tab with a spring in the linkage: tab deflection ∝ stick force Low IAS : air loads are small, the spring hardly compresses; the pilot moves the surface directly So at low speed you keep full control effectiveness High IAS : air loads hold the surface, the spring compresses and the tab does the workMaximum help at high speed , where stick forces would be greatest control force tab force horn, free to pivot on the hinge spring pilot input Spring tab at high IAS: spring compressed Air load holds the surface, so the tab does the work Tab moves opposite, at high IAS to the surface Stick force: light at high IAS · effectiveness: full at low IAS
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
17
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The spring tab cures the servo tab's weakness at low speed. The pilot's input reaches the control surface horn through a spring, and the tab is linked so that its deflection is proportional to the force the pilot applies. At low indicated airspeed the air loads on the surface are small, so the spring hardly compresses. The pilot simply moves the control surface directly, with the tab moving along with it, and you get full control effectiveness when you need large deflections. At high speed it is different. The dynamic pressure is so great that the surface resists moving, so the pilot's effort compresses the spring, the tab deflects opposite to the desired surface movement, and the tab's air load moves the surface, just like a servo tab. So the spring tab gives the most assistance at high speed, exactly where stick forces would otherwise be greatest. Its purpose: to reduce the effort needed to move the controls against high air loads.
Part 3 · Quick reference
Tabs at a glance Tab Moved by Moves, relative to surface Stick force Effectiveness Balance the control surface opposite less slightly reduced Anti-balance the control surface same waymore increased Servo the pilot (directly) opposite much less reduced, worst at low IAS Spring the pilot, via a spring opposite at high IAS less at high IAS full at low IAS; reduced at high IAS Trim the trim control only opposite reduced to zero slightly reduced
Trim tabs are covered with trimming in the next lesson. Every tab except the anti-balance tab moves opposite to its surface.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
18
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here are all the tabs side by side, because examiners love to mix them up. The balance tab is moved by the control surface, travels opposite to it, lightens the stick force and slightly reduces effectiveness. The anti-balance tab is also moved by the surface but travels the same way, so the stick force goes up and the effectiveness goes up. The servo tab is moved directly by the pilot, travels opposite to the surface it flies, gives very light forces, and loses effectiveness at low airspeed. The spring tab is moved by the pilot through a spring; it only really deflects at high speed, giving help there, while at low speed you have the full plain surface. Finally the trim tab, which we meet properly in the next lesson, is moved only by the trim control, travels opposite to the surface, and reduces the steady stick force to zero. Notice the pattern: every tab except the anti-balance tab moves opposite to its surface.
Part 3 · Hydraulic power
Power-assisted and fully powered controls Power-assisted : the pilot supplies a fixed share of the force, hydraulics the restSo natural feel is kept : stick force still rises with IAS² Fully powered : the pilot only moves a servo valve (and overcomes friction)The jack stops where the valve was set; trapped fluid locks the surface there Air loads cannot move the cockpit control: irreversible controls Fully powered flying control unit (schematic) fixed structure fluid piston servo valve pilot input hydraulic supply body moves control surface Pilot moves only the valve. Jack stops where the valve was set; trapped fluid locks it. Air loads cannot drive it back: IRREVERSIBLE
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
19
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
When aerodynamic balance cannot reduce the forces enough, hydraulic power is used. In a power-assisted system, the pilot still provides a fixed proportion of the force needed to oppose the hinge moment, and the hydraulic system provides the rest, usually most of it. Because a share of the real load still reaches the pilot, the natural feel is kept, and the stick force rises with the square of the indicated airspeed, just as in a manual control. For bigger and faster aircraft the hinge moments are so large that fully powered controls are needed. Now the pilot supplies no force to the surface at all, only enough to overcome friction and move a small servo valve. The valve lets fluid into one side of the jack, which moves the surface until it reaches the position the pilot selected, and then stops. Fluid trapped on both sides locks it there. Air loads cannot push the surface or the stick back, so these are called irreversible controls.
Part 3 · Hydraulic power
Artificial feel: the Q feel unit With fully powered controls the pilot feels no air load : easy to overstress the aircraft A Q feel unit senses dynamic pressure: pitot on one side of a diaphragm, static on the other It regulates hydraulic pressure to a feel jack: resistance ∝ ½ρV² , i.e. IAS² Stick force should also increase with stick displacement Simpler aircraft use springs; trimming can move the feel unit's datum Artificial (Q) feel unit pitot (total) static diaphragm pitot pressure static pressure regulates hydraulic pressure to the feel jack control column pitot − static = ½ρV² = Q feel force ∝ IAS², and grows with stick travel
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
20
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
With a fully powered control the pilot is completely cut off from the aerodynamic loads on the surfaces. That sounds pleasant, but it is dangerous: with no resistance, you could pull a large elevator deflection at high speed and overstress the aircraft without realising it. So artificial feel is built in. The usual device is a Q feel unit, where Q stands for dynamic pressure. Pitot pressure is fed to one side of a chamber and static pressure to the other, so the diaphragm between them senses pitot minus static, which is half rho V squared. The diaphragm regulates hydraulic pressure to a feel jack on the control circuit, giving a resisting force proportional to the indicated airspeed squared, just like a manual control. In addition, the force must grow as the stick is moved further. In the exam, the answer to how feel is provided in a fully powered system is: by an artificial feel, or Q feel, unit.
Part 4 · Flutter
Mass balance prevents flutter Flutter : an oscillation of a control surface coupled with bending and twisting of the structureCause: surface CG behind the hinge ; as the wing flexes, inertia makes the surface lag and swing It can be divergent , leading to structural failure within seconds Cure: a weight forward of the hinge , bringing the surface CG onto or slightly ahead of the hinge Forms: weight in a horn, along the leading edge, or on an internal arm Unbalanced: surface CG behind the hinge surface CG wing flexes up inertia: surface lags down Mass balanced: CG on or just ahead of the hinge balance weight surface CG at the hinge Weight forward of the hinge removes the inertia coupling
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
21
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Most control surfaces are mass balanced, and the reason is flutter. Flutter is an oscillation of a control surface that couples with the bending and twisting of the wing or tailplane under load. Imagine the wing flexing upward in turbulence. If the aileron's own centre of gravity is behind its hinge, its inertia makes it lag behind, so it deflects downward relative to the wing. That increases the lift on the wing, which flexes it further, and the cycle can feed itself. The oscillations can grow rapidly, and divergent flutter can tear a surface off in seconds. The cure is to add weight to the control surface forward of the hinge line, bringing its centre of gravity onto, or slightly ahead of, the hinge, exactly where the designer specifies. The inertia coupling disappears and flutter cannot develop. Remember: a mass balance is a weight forward of the hinge, and it prevents flutter. It does nothing for stick force.
Part 4 · Longitudinal control
What the elevator really controls Pitch control must balance the aircraft at all speeds, CG positions and configurations , and give an adequate pitch rate Elevator up: extra tail download , the nose pitches up As angle of attack grows, the extra download fades: a new equilibrium attitude Hold the elevator: the aircraft stays at that attitude; neutral: it returns At a given CG, one elevator angle = one attitude (one trimmed speed) Elevator up: tail download grows, nose rises extra tail download nose pitches up CG 1. Elevator up: the tail pushes down harder 2. Nose rises, angle of attack increases 3. Tail download falls back until moments balance 4. Hold the elevator: a new steady attitude
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
22
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Control in pitch comes from the elevators or an all-moving tailplane, and it must be able to balance the aircraft throughout its speed range, at every permitted centre of gravity position and configuration, and still give a decent rate of pitch for manoeuvres. Picture the aircraft in balance with the elevator neutral. Deflect the elevator upwards and the tail makes extra download, so the nose starts to pitch up. As the angle of attack increases, the tailplane's own angle of attack changes too and the extra download fades, until the pitching moments balance again at a new attitude. Keep the elevator where it is and the aircraft stays at that pitch attitude; it does not keep pitching. Return the elevator to neutral and the tail makes an upload, pitching the nose down again to where it started. So at a given centre of gravity position, each elevator angle corresponds to one attitude, one angle of attack and therefore one trimmed speed.
Part 4 · Longitudinal control
Which way does the tailplane push? High speed CG wing lift at CP CP well aft: big nose-down wing moment large tail DOWN-load small α · elevator slightly down Normal cruise CG wing lift at CP CP aft of CG: nose-down wing moment tail down-load elevator about neutral Low speed CG wing lift at CP CP forward: wing-body nose-up moment tail UP-load high α · elevator up The tailplane is usually symmetrical (or even inverted camber) because it must push both down and up . Pull back to pitch nose-up whatever its camber.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
23
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Which way does the tailplane actually push? It depends on speed and the centre of gravity. At normal cruise, with a normal centre of gravity, the elevator should be roughly neutral. The wing's centre of pressure lies well aft, so the wing gives a nose-down moment, and the tailplane balances it with a download. At higher than normal speeds the centre of pressure moves further back, the nose-down moment grows, and a bigger download is needed. But the aircraft is now at a lower angle of attack, so to get the right tail load the elevator ends up slightly down. At lower than normal speeds the centre of pressure moves forward, and the wing and fuselage may give a nose-up moment. Now the tailplane must provide an upload, and since the aircraft is at a high angle of attack, the elevator has been moved up. Because the tail pushes both ways, it is usually symmetrical, and whatever its camber, you still pull back to raise the nose.
Part 4 · Longitudinal control
Elevator demand with g, and in the flare In a pull-up the aircraft is rotating : the tail moves down through the air That raises the tail's angle of attack: extra pitch damping opposes the rotation So more elevator is needed than in 1 g: the extra angle is ∝ load factor (g) Elevator travel must allow the design limit g to be reached Most demanding: the landing flare , in ground effect , at forward CG Extra up elevator needed with load factor 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 0° 3° 6° 9° 12° 2.5 g: 2° + 1.5 × 3° = 6.5° limit g Load factor n (g) up elevator (from trim) 1 g: 2°
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
24
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
When the aircraft is pitching, for example in a pull-up, it is rotating about its centre of gravity, so the tail is moving downward through the air. That rotation increases the tailplane's angle of attack and creates extra aerodynamic damping that resists the pitch. The result is that a larger elevator angle is needed than for the same conditions in one g flight, and the additional elevator angle is proportional to the load factor. In the example on the chart, one g needs two degrees up from trim and each extra g needs three more, so a two point five g pull-up needs six and a half degrees. The elevator must have enough travel to reach the design limit load factor. The most demanding case of all for up elevator is the landing flare: at the most forward centre of gravity, the aircraft is nose-heavy, and in ground effect the reduced downwash at the tail makes it harder still to hold the nose up.
Part 4 · Longitudinal control
Ice on the tailplane Tailplane: usually symmetrical , set at a lower incidence than the wing so the wing stalls first Wing downwash gives it a negative angle of attack: it pushes down Ice on its leading edge lowers its stalling angle Lowering flaps increases downwash: the tail's angle grows more negative Tail stall: the download collapses, the nose pitches down , maybe beyond recovery Tailplane at negative angle of attack (side view) ice on the leading edge downwash from the wing tail download (balancing) 1. Flaps down: stronger downwash, more negative α 2. Ice: the tail stalls at a smaller angle 3. Tail stalls: its download collapses 4. Nose pitches DOWN, possibly beyond recovery
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
25
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The tailplane is an aerofoil too, usually symmetrical because it must push both ways. It is set at a lower angle of incidence than the wing, so that it will not stall before the wing and the pilot keeps pitch control right up to the wing stall. It also sits in the downwash from the wing, which reduces its effective angle of attack. Typically the tail works at a negative angle of attack, producing the download needed for balance. In the 3D view the tailplane is drawn upside down so its working side is on top. Now add ice to its leading edge. The aerofoil shape is spoiled and its stalling angle falls. Then lower the flaps: the downwash increases, so the tail's negative angle of attack grows. With ice, the tail can stall. Its download collapses, the aircraft pitches nose down, and the pitch-down may not be recoverable.
Part 4 · On the ground
Locks, checks and irreversible controls external gust lock On the ground: gust locks hold the surfaces so wind cannot slam them against their stops. Before flight: locks out, then a "full and free" check: each control moves smoothly in the correct sense and reaches a firm, solid stop. Servo-tab controls: a free cockpit control does not prove the surface is free. Control locks Prevent structural damage in gusty winds on the ground. Remove before flight.
Full and free Each control moves the right way , smoothly, to a firm, solid stop .
Servo-tab trap Cockpit controls move freely even with surface locks fitted : look at the surfaces.
Irreversible Powered surfaces move by the cockpit control only, not by air loads ; gusts cannot reach the stick.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
26
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
A few practical points that appear in the exam. Control locks, or gust locks, are fitted on the ground to stop the wind slamming the surfaces against their stops and damaging the structure in gusty conditions. They must be removed before flight; taking off with them in is a classic accident cause. Before every flight you make a full and free check: each control should move smoothly, in the correct sense, all the way to a firm, solid stop, with no binding and no springy rebound. Beware the servo tab trap: because the cockpit control drives only the tab, the controls in the cockpit will move fully and freely even with locks still clamped on the surfaces, so you must look at the surfaces themselves. Finally, remember the definition of an irreversible control: it can be moved by the cockpit control but not by the aerodynamic loads on the surface.
Summary
What to take into the exam Axes Elevator: pitch, lateral axis. Ailerons: roll, longitudinal axis. Rudder: yaw, normal axis. Elevon = aileron + elevator.
Hinge moment F × d. Load ∝ area × deflection × IAS². Double IAS: four times the stick force.
Aero balance Inset hinge, horn, internal: area ahead of hinge, lighter, same effectiveness. Overbalance: force reverses.
Balance tabs Balance: opposite, lighter, a bit less effective. Anti-balance: same way, heavier, more feel.
Servo / spring Servo: pilot moves tab, weak at low IAS, cockpit free with locks on. Spring: helps most at high IAS.
Powered Assisted keeps natural feel. Fully powered: irreversible, needs Q feel ∝ IAS² from pitot − static.
Mass balance Weight ahead of the hinge, CG on or just ahead of it: prevents flutter.
Pitch Elevator angle = attitude. Tail download in cruise, upload at low speed. Extra elevator ∝ g. Tail ice + flap: pitch-down.
Chapter 19 · Flight Controls and Control Forces
27
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Let us pull it together. The elevator gives pitch about the lateral axis, the ailerons roll about the longitudinal axis and the rudder yaw about the normal axis; an elevon combines aileron and elevator. The hinge moment is the load times its arm, and since the load depends on area, deflection and the indicated airspeed squared, doubling the speed quadruples the stick force. Inset hinges, horns and internal balance put area ahead of the hinge to lighten the control without losing effectiveness, but overbalance must never occur. Balance tabs move opposite and lighten; anti-balance tabs move the same way and add feel. Servo tabs let the pilot fly the surface through the tab, and spring tabs help most at high speed. Fully powered controls are irreversible and need Q feel. Mass balance prevents flutter. And in pitch, each elevator angle gives one attitude, the tail load changes with speed, more elevator is needed with g, and tailplane ice with flap can cause a dangerous pitch-down.