Principles of Flight · Chapter 16
Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability The CM against CL graph, what each part of the aeroplane adds, power and flap effects, stick-fixed and stick-free stability, stick force per g, and the control power needed for take-off, landing and high Mach number.
CG forward CG mid CG aft stick force load factor n 1 2 3 pull, and the stick pushes back © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Welcome to lesson sixteen. In the last lesson we found what makes an aeroplane stable in pitch. Now we put that on a graph, the pitching moment coefficient against the lift coefficient, and use it to see what the wing, fuselage, tail, engines and flaps each contribute. Then we move to the pilot's hands: how stability shows up as stick position and stick force, why friction and the trim tab matter, how manoeuvres feel through stick force per g, and how springs and bobweights tailor that feel. We finish with the control power needed for take-off, landing and high Mach number flight.
Lesson 16 roadmap
From graphs to the pilot's hand 1 · The CM –CL graph Trim point and slope as a picture of stability; pitch-up.
2 · Contributions Wing, fuselage, tailplane , longitudinal dihedral, downwash .
3 · Power and flaps Thrust line, propeller normal force, slipstream, high-lift devices.
4 · Elevator and trim Trim CL , stick-position stability, stick-fixed and stick-free .
5 · Stick force Trim tab, CG and friction effects on the force against speed.
6 · Manoeuvres Damping , the manoeuvre point and stick force per g .
7 · Feel devices Centring spring, Q-feel, down spring , bobweight .
8 · Control power Take-off, landing, manoeuvring; tail loads; Mach trim .
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here is the road map for this lesson. We begin with the most useful picture in the subject, the graph of pitching moment coefficient against lift coefficient, where the slope shows stability at a glance. Then we see what each part of the aeroplane contributes: the wing, the fuselage, the tailplane, and the downwash the tail flies in. Third, the effects of engine power and flaps. Fourth, the elevator: how it changes the trim point but not the stability, and the difference between stick-fixed and stick-free stability. Fifth, stick force against airspeed. Sixth, manoeuvres, aerodynamic damping and stick force per g, with a calculation. Seventh, the springs and bobweights designers use to tailor control feel. And finally, the control power needed for take-off, landing and manoeuvring, tail loads, and Mach trim.
The pitching moment coefficient
Pitching moment as a coefficient Pitching moment about the CG: M = CM · q · S · MAC ; nose up is positive Like CL , CM removes the effect of speed, density and size Every part adds its own CM : wing , fuselage and nacelles , tailplane , power All use the same q, wing area S and wing MAC, so they simply add up Plot the total CM against CL (or angle of attack) to see the stability M = CM · q · S · MAC M pitching moment about the CG, + nose up CM pitching moment coefficient q dynamic pressure, ½ρV² S wing area MAC mean aerodynamic chord wing + fuselage + nacelles + tailplane + power Sum the CM of every part, then plot it against C L The pitching moment as a coefficient
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Static longitudinal stability depends on how the pitching moment changes with angle of attack. Just as we turn lift into a lift coefficient, we turn the pitching moment into a pitching moment coefficient. The moment about the CG equals the pitching moment coefficient, times the dynamic pressure, times the wing area, times the mean aerodynamic chord. Nose up is positive. Using a coefficient removes the effect of speed, air density and size, so we can compare conditions fairly. The useful trick is that every part of the aeroplane, the wing, the fuselage and nacelles, the tailplane and the power plant, contributes its own pitching moment coefficient, and because they all share the same dynamic pressure, wing area and mean aerodynamic chord, they simply add up. Plot the total against lift coefficient, which stands in for angle of attack, and the stability of the whole aeroplane appears as one line.
Graphic presentation
The slope of CM against CL is the stability Trim where the line crosses CM = 0 Disturbed to a higher CL (point y): stable line gives negative CM , nose down, back to trim Disturbed to a lower CL (point x): positive CM , nose up, back to trim Negative slope = positive static stability ; steeper = more stableZero slope : neutral, will not hold trim. Positive slope : unstable, magnifies any disturbanceCL CM + − nose up nose down trim, CM = 0 x y stable: negative slope neutral: zero slope unstable: positive slope Steeper negative slope = more stable
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here is the graph. The aeroplane is in trim where its line crosses zero pitching moment. Now disturb it. On the green line, if a gust takes it to a higher lift coefficient, point y, the pitching moment there is negative, nose down, so the angle of attack falls back to trim. If it is disturbed to a lower lift coefficient, point x, the moment is positive, nose up, and again it returns. So a negative slope means positive static longitudinal stability, and the steeper the slope, the greater the stability. The flat yellow line has zero slope: disturb the aeroplane and nothing changes, so it is neutral and will not hold trim. The red line has a positive slope: disturb it to a higher lift coefficient and it gets a nose-up moment, which magnifies the disturbance. That aeroplane is unstable. Remember: at any lift coefficient, the stability is the slope.
When the slope changes
Stability can fade at high CL : pitch-up Normally the slope is the same at all CL : stability does not change with speed It can change at high CL (low speed) if the aeroplane has sweepback or a large contribution from power effects or big changes in downwash at the horizontal tail Slope flattens, becomes zero (neutral), then positive : the aeroplane pitches up CL CM + − nose up nose down stable slope zero slope: neutral pitch-up high speed low speed Causes: sweepback · power effects · downwash changes at the tail
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
For a conventional aeroplane the slope of the line usually stays the same whatever the lift coefficient, so stability does not change with speed. But there are three situations where it can change noticeably at high lift coefficient, which means low speed. First, if the aeroplane has sweepback. Second, if there is a large contribution from power effects. Third, if there are significant changes in the downwash at the horizontal tail. In this curve the slope is nicely negative at low lift coefficient, at high speed. As the lift coefficient rises, the slope gets smaller, so stability falls. Keep going and the slope reaches zero, neutral stability, and then turns positive. Now the aeroplane is unstable, and once the nose starts up it keeps going: that is pitch-up. A swept wing that stalls at the tips first is the classic case, because losing lift behind the CG gives a nose-up moment.
Contribution of the components
Adding up the parts: a typical build-up CL CM + − nose up nose down wing only wing + fuselage tailplane only complete aeroplane trim CL 0.7 CG at 30 % MAC Wing: positive slope AC ahead of CG: destabilising Fuselage and nacelles add more instability Tailplane: steep negative slope the big stabiliser Sum: negative slope stable at this CG The fuselage and nacelles are usually destabilising; the tailplane must stabilise the whole aeroplane at every expected CG position.
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
This graph builds up a typical aeroplane with power off and the CG at thirty per cent of the mean aerodynamic chord. The wing alone, blue, has a positive slope: with its aerodynamic centre ahead of the CG it is destabilising, as we saw last lesson. Add the fuselage and nacelles, grey, and the slope gets steeper still. A body in an airflow at an angle of attack has a pressure distribution that gives a nose-up, unstable moment that grows with angle of attack, while producing almost no lift. The tailplane alone, green, has a steep negative slope; it is highly stabilising. Add everything together and the complete aeroplane, the dark line, has a moderate negative slope, and trims at a lift coefficient of nought point seven. That is the designer's job: the tail contribution must be big enough that the complete aeroplane is stable at every CG position it will be loaded to.
Tail effectiveness 1
Longitudinal dihedral Longitudinal dihedral : the difference between wing and tailplane incidence For stability the tailplane incidence is smaller Example: wing 4°, tail 2°, gust adds 4° to both Wing 4° → 8°: +100 % lift. Tail 2° → 6°: +200 % lift So the tail lift grows proportionally more than the wing lift: a strong restoring moment Tail effectiveness also depends on downwash and dynamic pressure at the tail Wing α 4° → 8° +100 % lift Tailplane α 2° → 6° +200 % lift A +4° gust on both surfaces Tail incidence smaller than wing incidence
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
For a given CG, the tail moment depends on how effective the tailplane is, and one factor is longitudinal dihedral. This is the difference between the incidence of the wing and the incidence of the tailplane. For stability, the tailplane is set at a smaller incidence than the wing. Here is why it helps. Suppose the wing is at four degrees and the tail at two, and a vertical gust adds four degrees to both. The wing goes from four to eight degrees, double its angle, so its lift rises by about one hundred per cent. The tail goes from two to six degrees, three times its angle, so its lift rises by about two hundred per cent. The tail's lift grows proportionally much more than the wing's, which guarantees a strong restoring moment, enough to overcome the destabilising wing and fuselage. The other two factors in tail effectiveness are downwash and dynamic pressure at the tail.
Tail effectiveness 2
Downwash and dynamic pressure at the tail The tail sits in the wing's downwash , and downwash grows with wing α So the tail sees a smaller α change than the wing: 10° at the wing, 4° more downwash → only 6° at the tail Downwash decreases static longitudinal stability Anything that changes the downwash, such as flaps or propeller slipstream , changes stability Wing wake, fuselage boundary layer and power make q at the tail differ from free stream, usually lower free stream downwash ε Wing α change 10° Extra downwash − 4° Tail α change 6° q at tail usually lower than free stream (wake, fuselage, power) The tail flies in the wing's downwash
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The tailplane does not fly in undisturbed air. It sits in the downwash from the wing, and the downwash increases as the wing's angle of attack increases. So when the aeroplane is given a change in angle of attack, the tail sees a smaller change than the wing. For example, if a ten degree change at the wing causes four degrees more downwash at the tail, the tail sees only a six degree change. That reduces the tail's contribution: downwash decreases static longitudinal stability. Anything that alters the rate of change of downwash at the tail, such as flaps or propeller slipstream, directly changes the stability. The dynamic pressure at the tail matters too. Because of the wing wake, the fuselage boundary layer and power effects, it can be very different from the free stream, and it is usually lower, which reduces the efficiency of the tail.
Effect of CG position
Moving the CG rotates the line Large changes in stability come mainly from the change in the wing contribution CG moving aft: slope less negative → zero → positive The CG giving zero slope is the neutral point , here 40 % MAC The NP is the aerodynamic centre of the whole aeroplane It is the most aft CG without static instability CL CM + − nose up nose down 10 % 20 % 30 % 40 % = NP 50 % CG moving aft: slope less negative, then zero, then positive CG, % MAC
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now let us move the CG on the graph. If the incidence of every surface stays fixed, moving the CG changes the stability a lot, mainly because the wing's contribution changes, as its arm to the CG changes. With the CG at ten per cent of the mean aerodynamic chord, the line slopes steeply down: very stable. At twenty and thirty per cent the slope is less negative: less stable. At forty per cent the line is flat. That CG position, giving zero slope and neutral stability, is the neutral point. With the CG there, every change of total lift acts right at the CG, so no change of pitching moment results; that is why we call the neutral point the aerodynamic centre of the whole aeroplane. At fifty per cent the slope is positive: unstable. So the neutral point marks the most aft CG position without static instability.
Power effects 1
Direct effects of power Power effects are biggest at high power and low airspeed : take-off, approach, go-around Thrust line below the CG : more thrust gives a nose-up moment: destabilising Propeller ahead of the CG : inclined airflow through the disc creates a normal force at the propellerThat normal force grows with α , so with the propeller ahead of the CG it is destabilising Largest at high power and low dynamic pressure , and the further the propeller from the CG thrust arm more thrust: nose up normal force at the propeller inclined airflow Propeller ahead of the CG: grows with α → destabilising Direct effects of power
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
10
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Power affects stability most when the aeroplane is at high power and low airspeed, during take-off, approach and go-around. The direct effects come from the forces of the propulsion unit itself. First, the vertical position of the thrust line. On this airliner the engines hang below the wing, so the thrust line is below the CG. Increase thrust, and the thrust times its arm below the CG gives a positive, nose-up moment, which is destabilising. Second, a propeller ahead of the CG. When the propeller disc is inclined to the airflow, it turns the air, and the change of momentum creates a normal force at the propeller, upwards when the angle of attack rises. That force grows with angle of attack, and acting ahead of the CG it is destabilising. It is biggest at high power and low dynamic pressure, and the further the propeller is from the CG.
Power effects 2 and flaps
Slipstream, downwash and flaps Slipstream raises q at the tail : can be stabilising Extra wing lift in the slipstream lets the wing work at a lower α : tail contribution falls Slipstream deflected down increases downwash : destabilising; jet exhaust under the tail too Flaps : more downwash, less q at the tail: usually destabilising Least stability at high power, high CL , low q : power approach and go-around. Propeller worse than jet The power-on neutral point may set the aft CG limit slipstream / jet induced flow Higher q at the tail stabilising Wing at lower α for the same CL tail contributes less Slipstream deflected down: more downwash destabilising Jet exhaust passing under the tail destabilising (small) Flaps: more downwash, less q at the tail usually destabilising Indirect effects: the flow round the tail
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
11
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The indirect effects of power come from the slipstream and other induced flow changing the forces on the wing, fuselage and tail, and they matter most for propeller aeroplanes. The faster slipstream raises the dynamic pressure at the tail, which can be stabilising. But the extra lift on the part of the wing in the slipstream means the aeroplane works at a lower angle of attack for the same lift coefficient, and that generally reduces the tail's contribution. The slipstream is also deflected downwards by the propeller's normal force, adding downwash at the tail, which is destabilising. In a jet, exhaust passing under the tail has a similar but small effect. Flaps increase downwash and reduce dynamic pressure at the tail, so they are usually destabilising too. Put together, stability is lowest at high power, high lift coefficient and low dynamic pressure, so in a power approach or go-around, and the power-on neutral point may set the aft CG limit.
Elevator and trim
The elevator moves the trim point, not the slope Holding the elevator 10° up moves the CM line up , parallel to itself The aeroplane now trims at a higher CL , a lower speed The slope is unchanged : same static stability A change in elevator position does not alter the tail contribution to stability So each elevator position corresponds to one trim CL (one trim speed) CL CM + − nose up nose down trim, elevator 0° trim, elevator 10° up up elevator Parallel lines: same stability, higher trim CL
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
12
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
What does the elevator do on this graph? With the CG at twenty per cent and the elevator at zero, the blue line trims at a lift coefficient of nought point two. Now hold the elevator ten degrees up. The tail produces a nose-up moment at every angle of attack, so the whole line moves up, parallel to itself, and now crosses zero at a higher lift coefficient, nought point seven. The aeroplane trims at a higher lift coefficient, which in level flight means a lower speed. But look at the slope: unchanged. The static stability is exactly the same. This is an important exam statement: a change in elevator position does not alter the tail's contribution to stability; it only changes the trim. So for a given CG, each elevator position corresponds to one trim lift coefficient, and so one trim speed.
Stick-position stability
Elevator to trim, and stick position Each CG gives a line of trim CL against elevator ; its slope shows stability CG aft: a given elevator movement gives a bigger change in trim CL : less stable, more controllable At the neutral point the line is flat Stick-position stability : stick aft to trim slower , forward to trim fasterUnstable: stick aft for a higher speed, forward for a lower one: unacceptable CL elevator up down 10 % 20 % 30 % 40 % NP Trim CL against elevator, for four CG positions EAS elevator stable unstable Stable: more up elevator (stick aft) for a lower trim speed
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
13
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Since every elevator position gives one trim lift coefficient, we can plot elevator angle to trim against lift coefficient, one line for each CG position. With a forward CG, the line is steep: lots of elevator for a small change in trim. As the CG moves aft the slope decreases, so a given control movement gives a bigger change in trim lift coefficient. That is decreasing stability and increasing controllability. With the CG at the neutral point the line is flat. Each lift coefficient also matches one airspeed in level flight, so we can plot elevator to trim against equivalent airspeed, the lower graph. With the CG ahead of the neutral point, the pilot must move the stick aft to trim at a lower speed and forward to trim at a higher speed. That is stick-position stability, and it is highly desirable. An unstable aeroplane needs the stick aft to go faster: completely illogical.
Stick fixed and stick free
Holding the stick, or letting it go Stick-fixed stability: the elevator is held in place; seen in stick position to trimStick-free stability: the pilot lets go and the elevator is free to float under its hinge momentsWhen the tail's α rises, a free elevator floats trailing edge up , with the airflow That reduces the tail lift change : less stabilising So the stick-free neutral point is further forward and the stick-free margin smaller Stick force stability depends on the stick-free case; aerodynamic balance reduces float ΔLt Stick fixed elevator held: full tail lift change ΔLt Stick free elevator floats up: less tail lift change A gust raises the tail's angle of attack Stick-free neutral point is ahead of the stick-fixed one
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
14
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
So far we have assumed the pilot holds the elevator still. That is stick-fixed stability, and it shows up as the stick position needed to trim. But much of the time the pilot is not holding a force; the aeroplane is trimmed and the elevator is free to float under its own hinge moments. That is the stick-free case. Here is the difference. When a gust raises the tail's angle of attack, a free elevator floats with the airflow, trailing edge up. That reduces the extra lift the tail produces, so the restoring moment is smaller. The aeroplane is less stable stick-free than stick-fixed, which means the stick-free neutral point lies further forward, and the stick-free static margin is smaller. The stick forces the pilot feels depend on stick-free stability. Designers reduce the float with aerodynamic balance on the elevator, and adjust the forces with tabs and springs.
Stick-force stability
Stick force against airspeed EAS (kt) stick force PULL PUSH 1 2 3 60 100 140 180 220 260 Each curve: a different nose-up trim tab setting (less tab for 2 and 3) EAS force Friction band masks weak stick force stability: a whole band of speeds "trims" Properly trimmed: push to go faster, pull to go slower . That is a stable "feel" for airspeed.
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
15
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The pilot actually feels force, not position, so stick-force stability is what matters day to day. On the left, each curve shows stick force against equivalent airspeed for one trim tab setting. At its trim speed the force is zero. To trim at point one, a lot of up elevator is needed, held by a nose-up tab. To trim at the higher speeds two and three, less and less nose-up tab is needed. Part of the force depends on the tab setting and varies with dynamic pressure, so with the square of the airspeed. On every curve, below the trim speed the pilot must pull and above it must push. That is positive stick-force stability, a stable feel for airspeed. On the right is the effect of friction in the control system: the line becomes a band. Where the stick-force gradient is weak, a wide friction band completely hides it, so good maintenance of the control runs really matters.
Effect of CG on stick force
CG aft: a weaker feel for airspeed Same trim speed, different CG: moving the CG aft reduces the stick force gradient Smaller forces are needed to move away from trim speed Gradient zero : the CG is at the neutral point ; neutral stabilityCG behind the NP: push to fly slower , pull to fly faster : instability Feel is weakest at low speed, high power and aft CG EAS stick force PULL PUSH 10 % 20 % 30 % 40 % NP 50 % trim speed CG aft: gradient falls; zero at the NP; reversed behind it CG, % MAC
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
16
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now keep the trim speed fixed and change the CG. With the CG forward, at ten per cent, the stick force line is steep: a large pull is needed to slow down and a large push to speed up. As the CG moves aft, the line rotates through the trim speed and gets flatter, so smaller and smaller forces are needed to move the aeroplane away from its trim speed. At the neutral point, here forty per cent, the gradient is zero: you can change speed with no force at all, and the aeroplane has neutral stability. Move the CG behind the neutral point and the gradient reverses: you need a push to fly slower and a pull to fly faster, which is stick-force instability. Notice also that the gradient is low at low airspeeds. Combine low speed, high power and a CG near the aft limit, and the pilot's feel for airspeed will be weak.
Manoeuvre stability 1
Aerodynamic damping in pitch When the aircraft pitches, it rotates about the CG and the tail gets a pitching velocity Nose pitching up: the tail moves down and meets an upward component of airflow Added to the TAS, this raises the tail's α : more tail lift opposing the pitch It exists only while the motion lasts : this is aerodynamic damping For the same pitch rate, higher TAS → smaller Δα → less damping Example: tail moving down at 1.3 m/s: Δα 0.75° at 100 m/s, only 0.38° at 200 m/s pitching nose up tail moves down TAS upward flow relative flow at the tail Δα Extra tail α opposes the pitch: damping Higher TAS → smaller Δα → less damping Aerodynamic damping in pitch
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
17
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
When the pilot pitches the aircraft, it rotates about the CG, and the tailplane, far behind, moves with a pitching velocity. If the nose is pitching up, the tail is moving down. A tail moving down meets an upward component of airflow, and when you add that to the true airspeed, the relative airflow at the tail is tilted, increasing the tail's angle of attack. More tail lift means a nose-down moment that opposes the nose-up pitching. Because it is caused by the motion and only exists while the motion lasts, it is called damping in pitch, or aerodynamic damping. It makes the aeroplane slightly more stable in manoeuvres than in steady flight. Now the important part: for the same pitch rate, a higher true airspeed makes the change in tail angle of attack smaller. In our example, at one hundred metres per second it is three quarters of a degree; at two hundred, less than half that.
Manoeuvre stability 2
The manoeuvre point Damping gives more stability in manoeuvres than in steady 1 g flight The CG where tail and wing moments would balance during manoeuvres is the manoeuvre point It lies aft of the neutral point CG to manoeuvre point = manoeuvre margin , bigger than the static margin Rarely critical: stable in 1 g flight ⇒ stable in manoeuvres 0 % 10 % 20 % 30 % 40 % 50 % 60 % fwd limit high stick force aft limit low stick force neutral point 1 g manoeuvre point in manoeuvres static margin manoeuvre margin The manoeuvre point lies aft of the NP Stable in 1 g flight → stable in manoeuvres
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
18
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Because of aerodynamic damping, the aeroplane is more stable when it is manoeuvring than it appears in steady one g flight. We can describe this with another reference point. The CG position at which the tail moment and the wing moment would be equal during manoeuvring is called the manoeuvre point. It is a kind of neutral point for manoeuvres, and because of the extra damping it lies further aft than the ordinary neutral point. The distance from the CG to the manoeuvre point is the manoeuvre margin, and it is always bigger than the static margin. In most cases the manoeuvre point is not a critical item. If an aeroplane is statically stable in one g flight, which the aft CG limit guarantees, it will definitely be stable in manoeuvring flight as well.
Manoeuvre stability 3
Stick force per g load factor n stick force (N) too steep: tiring about right too light: overstress 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Force rises steadily with g, from zero at 1 g CG, % MAC stick force per g low altitude high altitude 10 20 30 40 50 Falls as the CG moves aft and as altitude rises The forward CG limit may be set to stop the gradient becoming too high; at the aft limit it may reach its lower limit.
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
19
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The most direct measure of manoeuvring stability is a plot of stick force against load factor. A stable aeroplane needs a steadily increasing pull for each extra g, starting from zero at one g when it is trimmed. That slope is the manoeuvring stick force gradient, or stick force per g. It must be positive, and it must be the right size. Too high, and the aeroplane is hard work and tiring to manoeuvre. Too low, and a pilot using light forces could overstress the aeroplane without meaning to. On the right you can see what changes it. High static stability gives high manoeuvring stability and a high stick force per g, so the forward CG limit might be set to stop it becoming excessive. As the CG moves aft the gradient decreases, and the lower acceptable limit may be reached. And at high altitude the gradient is lower than at low altitude, because of reduced damping.
Worked example
Calculating stick force per g The aircraft starts at 1 g : count only the extra g Gradient 40 N per g, limit 3.8 g: force = (3.8 − 1) × 40 = 112 N Reverse: 150 N pull to reach 2.5 g → 150 ÷ (2.5 − 1) = 100 N per g Trap: 150 ÷ 2.5 = 60 is wrong Higher altitude at the same IAS: lower stick force per g n (g) force (N) 112 1 2 3 3.8 extra g = 3.8 − 1 = 2.8 2.8 g × 40 N per g = 112 N Trap: the aircraft starts at 1 g, not 0 g Force to reach the limit load factor
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
20
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Let us calculate. The key fact is that the aircraft is already at one g in level flight with no stick force, so only the extra g needs force. Suppose the stick force per g is forty newtons and the limit load factor is three point eight. The extra load factor is three point eight minus one, which is two point eight, and two point eight times forty gives one hundred and twelve newtons. Now go the other way. A pilot needs a pull of one hundred and fifty newtons to reach two point five g. Subtract one g first, giving one point five, then divide: one hundred and fifty divided by one point five is one hundred newtons per g. The classic wrong answer divides by two point five, giving sixty. Do not fall for it. And remember that at a higher altitude, at the same indicated airspeed, the stick force per g will be lower.
Effect of altitude
Damping falls with altitude Pitch damping depends on air density At the same IAS, altitude means higher TAS , so a smaller tail α change for a given pitch rate Damping ∝ √σ , the same ratio as EAS to TAS ISA 40 000 ft : σ = 0.246, √σ ≈ 0.5: damping halved So stick force per g falls and dynamic stability is reduced at high altitude damping (sea level = 1) altitude (ft) 0 1.00 10,000 0.86 20,000 0.73 30,000 0.61 40,000 0.50 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 Damping ∝ √σ (like EAS/TAS) 40 000 ft ISA: σ = 0.246, √σ ≈ 0.5: half the sea level damping Same IAS, higher altitude
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
21
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Pitch damping depends on air density. At high altitude, flying at the same indicated airspeed means a much higher true airspeed, so the same pitch rate produces a smaller change in the tail's angle of attack, and less damping. In fact aerodynamic damping is proportional to the square root of the relative density, the same ratio that links equivalent airspeed and true airspeed. In the standard atmosphere at forty thousand feet the relative density is about nought point two five, and its square root is about nought point five. So damping at forty thousand feet is roughly half its sea level value. Two consequences follow. The manoeuvring stick force per g falls as altitude increases, so it is easier to pull more g than intended. And dynamic stability, which relies on damping, is reduced at high altitude, a point we return to in lesson seventeen.
Tailoring control forces
Springs, Q-feel and bobweights Centring spring : force grows with stick displacement; helps airspeed and manoeuvre stick force stability, most at low speed Q-feel : spring stiffness varies with dynamic pressure , so its help does not fade with speedDown spring : pre-loaded, pulls elevator down; adds a constant pull: airspeed gradient up, per-g unchanged Bobweight : same as a down spring in 1 g, but its weight grows with g : both gradients upNone of them changes the aeroplane's static stability ; they change the feel to elevator centring spring down spring pre-loaded, pulls elevator down bobweight weighs more with g control column Shaping the stick forces Q-feel: a spring whose stiffness rises with dynamic pressure Schematic only
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
22
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Control forces should reflect the aeroplane's stability, but they must also stay tolerable, so manual control systems use several devices. A stick centring spring adds a force that grows with stick displacement. It adds to both airspeed and manoeuvring stick force stability, most at low speed where the control deflections are large, and least at high speed. A Q-feel spring, whose stiffness varies with dynamic pressure, keeps its contribution as speed rises. A down spring is a long pre-loaded spring pulling the elevator down, nose down. It adds a constant pull force whatever the speed or deflection, so after re-trimming the airspeed stick force gradient is steeper; but it does nothing to the stick force per g. A bobweight is a mass in the control system. In one g it acts exactly like a down spring, but in a manoeuvre it weighs more with every g, so it also increases the stick force per g, discouraging the pilot from pulling too much.
Longitudinal control 1
Enough elevator to reach CL max High stability means great resistance to displacement: the limits of controllability set the upper limit of stability Three critical cases: manoeuvring , take-off and landing ; any one may set the forward CG limit Manoeuvring: the elevator must trim the aeroplane at CL max or the limit load factor Example: full up elevator reaches CL max only with the CG at or aft of 18 % MAC Supersonic flight: stability rises (CP aft) and controls weaken, so all-moving tailplanes are used CL up elevator to trim (°) maximum elevator deflection CL max 10 % 18 % 20 % 30 % 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 CG ahead of 18 % MAC: full up elevator cannot trim at CL max
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
23
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
An aeroplane needs adequate controllability as well as stability, and the two compete. High static stability means great resistance to displacement, so the most critical cases for control come when stability is high, with a forward CG. In other words, the lower limits of controllability set the upper limit of stability, the forward CG limit. There are three critical flight conditions: manoeuvring, take-off and landing. For manoeuvring, the elevator must be powerful enough to trim the aeroplane at its maximum usable lift coefficient or its limit load factor. In this example, moving the CG forward needs more and more up elevator for each lift coefficient, and with the CG ahead of eighteen per cent of the chord, full up elevator cannot trim the aeroplane at C L max. In supersonic flight stability rises sharply and controls lose effectiveness, so powerful all-moving tailplanes are used.
Longitudinal control 2
Take-off and landing requirements Take-off : the elevator must rotate to the take-off attitude before take-off speedNose-down moments from rolling friction and the CG ahead of the main wheels ; propeller slipstream helps the tail Landing : most critical with CG forward , flaps full , power idle Ground effect cuts downwash: less tail download, nose-down: up to 15° more up elevator to trim at CL max Too much trim can reduce elevator effectiveness for take-off or landing Take-off rotation rolling friction tail download CG ahead of the main wheels + friction: both nose down; the tail must beat them Landing in ground effect normal downwash reduced downwash Less downwash → less tail download → nose down: up to 15° more up elevator to trim at CL max
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
24
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
At take-off, the elevator must be powerful enough to rotate the aeroplane to the take-off attitude before reaching take-off speed. The critical moment is with the nose wheel just unloaded. Two nose-down moments work against the tail: rolling friction at the main wheels, below the CG, and the CG itself sitting ahead of the main wheels. A propeller aeroplane at take-off power gets help from its slipstream over the tail; a jet does not. At landing, the most critical case is a forward CG, full flap and idle power, the most stable configuration. And there is ground effect. Near the ground the wing's downwash is reduced, so the tail's download falls and the nose wants to drop. A typical propeller aeroplane may need as much as fifteen degrees more up elevator to trim at C L max in ground effect. Excessive use of trim can also leave the elevator short of authority.
Tailplane loads
Why the tail usually pushes down To trim, the tail balances the wing's nose-down moment about its AC and the lift–weight couple With a typical CG this needs a download on the tail CG forward : bigger download, so the wing must lift W + download Result: higher stall speed , more induced drag and fuel burn Example: W 60 000 N, download 3000 N → wing lift 63 000 N; VS up √1.05 ≈ 2.5 % CG aft : smaller download: lower VS , faster cruise, but less stabilitywing lift W large download CG forward wing lift W small download CG aft Wing lift = W + tail download → higher VS and more drag
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
25
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
In trimmed flight the tailplane has to balance the pitching moments of the rest of the aeroplane. The cambered wing has its constant nose-down moment about the aerodynamic centre, and the lift and weight form a couple depending on where the CG is. With typical loading the tail must push down to hold the nose up, so it carries a download. Move the CG forward and that download gets bigger. The wing then has to lift the weight plus the tail download. For example, an aeroplane weighing sixty thousand newtons with a three thousand newton tail download needs sixty-three thousand newtons of wing lift. The stall speed rises with the square root of that ratio, about two and a half per cent, and induced drag and fuel burn go up too. With the CG aft, the download shrinks, so stall speed is a little lower and cruise a little faster, but stability is lower. That is the trade inside the CG limits.
High Mach number
Mach tuck and the Mach trim system Beyond MCRIT a shock at the root of a swept wing reduces lift ahead of the CG It also reduces downwash at the tail : both give a nose-down moment Instead of more push for more speed, a pull is needed: speed instability Nose down → Mach up → more nose down: Mach tuck ("tuck under") Mach trim , sensed by Mach number: elevator up , tailplane incidence reduced , or fuel aft It over-compensates to keep the stick force gradient ; works only at high Mach nose-down pitch: tuck M > M crit : shock at the swept wing root lift lost ahead of the CG less downwash at the tail nose down → faster → more nose down Mach trim: elevator up, less tailplane incidence, or fuel aft; more than just the trim change Mach tuck
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
26
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
At high Mach number, a swept-wing jet meets one more longitudinal problem. Above the critical Mach number, a shock wave forms near the root of the swept wing. That destroys lift ahead of the CG, and it reduces the downwash at the tailplane, so the tail's download falls. Both give a nose-down pitching moment. The result is instability with speed: instead of needing an increasing push to go faster, the pilot needs a pull to stop the aircraft accelerating. A small increase in Mach number pitches the nose down, which increases the Mach number, which increases the nose-down moment. This is Mach tuck, also called high speed tuck or tuck under, and it would limit the maximum operating speed. So a Mach trim system is fitted. Sensing Mach number, it raises the elevator, reduces the trimming tailplane incidence or moves fuel aft, by more than the trim change alone, to keep the required stick force gradient. It works only at high Mach numbers.
Summary
What to take into the exam CM –CL slope Negative slope = stable; zero = neutral; positive = unstable. Pitch-up: sweep, power, downwash.
Components Wing and fuselage destabilise; tail stabilises. Tail incidence smaller (longitudinal dihedral).
Downwash and power Downwash, thrust below CG, prop ahead of CG, flaps: destabilising. Worst at high power, low speed.
Elevator Moves the trim point, not the slope. Stick aft to trim slower. Stick-free NP ahead of stick-fixed.
Stick force Push to go faster. Gradient falls as CG moves aft; zero at the NP. Friction band masks it.
Damping Opposes pitch rate; ∝ √σ; halved at 40 000 ft. Manoeuvre point aft of NP.
Per g Subtract 1 g. Down spring: airspeed only. Bobweight: airspeed and per g.
Control limits Fwd CG limit from take-off, landing (ground effect) and CL max trim. Mach trim fights tuck.
Chapter 16 · Pitching Moments, Stick Force and Manoeuvre Stability
27
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To sum up. On the graph of pitching moment coefficient against lift coefficient, a negative slope means stable, zero neutral and positive unstable; sweepback, power and downwash changes can cause pitch-up at high lift coefficient. The wing and fuselage are destabilising, the tail stabilising, helped by a smaller tail incidence. Downwash, a thrust line below the CG, a propeller ahead of the CG and flaps are destabilising, worst at high power and low speed. The elevator moves the trim point but not the slope, and the stick-free neutral point is ahead of the stick-fixed one. Stick force stability means push to go faster; the gradient falls as the CG moves aft and is zero at the neutral point. Damping falls with altitude, and the manoeuvre point lies aft of the neutral point. For stick force per g, subtract one g. A down spring changes only the airspeed gradient, a bobweight both. And Mach trim fights Mach tuck.