Principles of Flight · Chapter 11
Wing Design and Stall Behaviour How the aerofoil section and the planform decide where a wing stalls first and how it behaves: root and tip stall, washout, slots, stall strips, vortex generators, the swept wing’s pitch-up, fences and vortilons, deep stall and the stick pusher.
tip stall on a swept wing deep stall: T-tail in the wake © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Welcome to the second lesson on stalling. Every wing stalls at its critical angle, but how the aeroplane behaves at that moment depends on where along the span the stall begins. A wing that stalls at the root first gives warning buffet and drops its nose gently. A wing that stalls at the tips can roll violently, lose aileron control or, if it is swept, pitch up into an even deeper stall. In this lesson we see how the aerofoil section and the planform decide the stall pattern, how designers tame tip stall with washout, slots, stall strips, vortex generators, fences and vortilons, and why swept-wing aircraft with T-tails need a stick pusher.
Lesson map
Where the stall begins decides how the aeroplane behaves 1 · The section Nose radius, thickness and camber decide the stalling angle and how sudden the stall is.
2 · The planform Rectangular wings stall at the root, tapered and swept wings at the tip.
3 · The cures Washout, section change, slots, stall strips, vortex generators, fences, vortilons.
4 · Deep stall Swept wing plus T-tail: pitch-up, a locked-in stall, and the stick pusher.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
In the last lesson we saw that every wing stalls at its critical angle of attack. This lesson is about the character of the stall: does it come gently, with plenty of warning and a natural nose drop, or suddenly, with a wing drop or a pitch-up? We look first at the aerofoil section, because the shape of the nose and the thickness and camber of a section decide its stalling angle and how abruptly its lift collapses. Second, the planform, because different parts of the span reach their stalling angle at different times. Third, the many cures designers use to make the root stall first and keep the ailerons working. And finally the deep stall, the dangerous combination of a swept wing and a T-tail, and the stick pusher that prevents it.
Part 1 · The section
Section shape and the character of the stall Features that matter: leading edge radius , thickness-chord ratio , camber (especially near the leading edge ) Also the chordwise position of maximum thickness and maximum camber Sharper nose, thinner section, maximum thickness and camber further aft : a more sudden stallThat describes sections designed for high speed A sudden stall needs an artificial warning , or even a stall prevention device Gentle stall: NACA 4415 large nose radius · thick (15%) · camber forward Sudden stall: NACA 0006 small nose radius · thin (6%) · no camber High-speed sections are the sudden stallers
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The shape of the aerofoil section decides how it stalls. With some sections the stall comes very suddenly and the drop in lift is dramatic; with others the approach is gradual and the loss of lift much less alarming. Four features matter: the leading edge radius, the thickness-chord ratio, the camber, especially the amount of camber near the leading edge, and the chordwise positions of the maximum thickness and maximum camber. Compare the two sections, both drawn from the real NACA equations. The fifteen per cent thick, cambered section has a generous rounded nose and stalls gently. The six per cent symmetrical section has a sharp nose and stalls abruptly. In general, the sharper the nose, the thinner the section, and the further aft the maximum thickness and camber, the more sudden the stall. Unfortunately that is exactly the kind of section designed for efficient high-speed flight, so such wings often need an artificial stall warning, or even a device that prevents the stall.
Part 1 · The section
Gentle and sudden stalls on the lift curve 0 5 10 15 20 25 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 angle of attack α (degrees) CL gentle: 1.75 at 18° sudden: 1.00 at 11° lift collapses Sharper nose, thinner section, thickness and camber further aft: → stall at a smaller α → stall more suddenly Rounder nose, thicker section, camber near the leading edge: → stall at a larger α → stall more gently A given section always stalls at the same angle of attack Because a section always stalls at the same α, designers can choose sections along the span to encourage the stall at the root or delay it at the tip.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here are typical lift curves for those two kinds of section, computed from a smooth model. The thick section with a round nose and forward camber keeps its flow attached to about eighteen degrees, reaches the higher C L max, and then loses lift gradually; the pilot feels buffet and mushy controls long before anything dramatic happens. The thin, sharp-nosed section stalls at only about eleven degrees with a lower C L max, and its lift collapses abruptly. So, for the exam: a small leading edge radius gives a stall at a smaller angle of attack and a more sudden stall; a large thickness-chord ratio gives a stall at a higher angle and a gentler one; camber near the leading edge raises the stalling angle. And because any given section always stalls at the same angle of attack, a designer can use different sections at different points along the span to make the stall start exactly where it is wanted.
Part 2 · The planform
Where along the span does the stall begin? 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25 spanwise position (0 = root, 1 = tip) local CL ÷ wing CL rectangular stall starts at the ROOT elliptical stall everywhere at once taper ratio 0.25 stall starts near the TIP Lifting-line solution, aspect ratio 6, no twist, same section all along The stall starts where the local lift coefficient is highest , because that part of the span reaches the section’s CL max first.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
On a real wing, separation does not happen everywhere at once. Each part of the span works at its own local lift coefficient, and the stall starts wherever that local value first reaches the section’s maximum. This chart shows the local lift coefficient across the semi-span, as a fraction of the whole wing’s, worked out with lifting-line theory for three untwisted wings of the same aspect ratio. On the rectangular wing, shown in blue, the local value is highest at the root and falls towards the tip, so the root stalls first. On the elliptical wing, in green, it is the same everywhere, so the whole span stalls together, which is efficient but gives no warning. On the highly tapered wing, in red, the root works at a low local value and the peak is out at about three quarters of the span, so the stall begins near the tip. The next slides show why, and what each pattern means for the pilot.
Part 2 · The planform
Tip vortices protect the tips of a rectangular wing On a rectangular wing the tip vortices are strong They induce downwash that grows from root to tip Downwash reduces the effective angle of attack , most at the tips So the root reaches the critical angle first On a tapered wing the small tip cannot support strong vortices; they form further inboard and protect the root instead downwash: weakest at the root, strongest near the tips Effective α = geometric α − induced angle effective α highest at the root → root stalls first
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Why does a rectangular wing stall at the root? Look at the tip vortices. On a rectangular wing, the tips carry plenty of chord and lift, so the tip vortices are strong. They induce downwash over the wing, and on an untwisted rectangular wing that downwash increases from the root to the tip. Downwash tilts the relative airflow downward, so the effective angle of attack is the geometric angle minus the induced angle. The tips, sitting in the strongest downwash, work at the smallest effective angle of attack, and the root, with the least downwash, works at the largest. As the aircraft slows and the angle increases, the root reaches the critical angle first. A tapered wing is the opposite case: its small tip chord cannot support strong vortices, so they effectively form closer to the root, reducing the effective angle of attack there instead, and the tips are left to stall first.
Part 2 · Rectangular wing
The rectangular wing: a well-behaved root stall Separation starts at the root and spreads outward Lift lost near the CG, so little tendency to roll ; it sinks more or less wings level Lift lost ahead of the CG: the CP moves rearward and the nose drops , reducing α The root wake buffets the tail : natural warning Ailerons stay in attached flow , so they keep working ailerons in attached flow stall starts here spreads outward tailplane buffeted by the root wake Lift lost near the CG, ahead of it: the CP moves aft and the nose drops; little rolling tendency
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
On a rectangular wing, separation begins at the root and spreads outward towards the tips. That gives almost ideal behaviour. The lift is lost first close to the aircraft’s centre line, near the centre of gravity, so even if one side stalls slightly before the other there is little tendency to roll; the aircraft sinks but stays more or less wings level. The lost lift is also ahead of the centre of gravity, so the centre of pressure moves rearward and the nose drops by itself, reducing the angle of attack: the aircraft naturally moves away from the stall. The turbulent wake from the root streams back over the rear fuselage and the tailplane and shakes them, giving the pilot aerodynamic buffet as a warning. And the ailerons, out towards the tips, remain in attached flow, so they keep working as the stall develops.
Part 2 · Rectangular wing
The four marks of a good stall, and the catch A rectangular wing shows all four of the most desirable stall characteristics:
Aileron effectiveness The ailerons sit in attached flow , so roll control remains.
Nose drop CP moves aft ; the nose drops and α reduces by itself .
Aerodynamic buffet The root wake shakes the tail : a natural warning.
No violent wing drop Lift lost near the centre line : little rolling moment.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here are the four marks of a good stall, which the rectangular wing shows naturally. First, aileron effectiveness: the ailerons stay in attached flow, so the pilot keeps roll control. Second, nose drop: the centre of pressure moves aft as the root stalls, so the nose falls and the angle of attack reduces without the pilot doing anything. Third, aerodynamic buffet: the wake from the root shakes the tail and warns the pilot. Fourth, the absence of violent wing drop, because the lift is lost close to the centre line where it has little leverage to roll the aircraft. So why are most modern wings not rectangular? Because a rectangular wing has poor structural properties, with a large bending moment at the root for its lift, and it is not very efficient aerodynamically. Most aircraft therefore have tapered and often swept wings, and those stall the wrong way unless the designer does something about it.
Part 2 · Tapered wing
The tapered wing tends to stall at the tips Separation tends to start in the region of the tips Result: aileron buffet and perhaps a violent wing drop Wing drop at the stall increases the tendency to spin No buffet on the tail and no strong nose-down pitch Little, if any, aileron effectiveness stall starts near the tip root still flying • Aileron buffet, little aileron control • Possible violent wing drop → spin • No tail buffet, no strong nose-down pitch
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now the tapered wing. Here separation tends to begin in the region of the wing tips, and if a real wing were allowed to stall that way, the results would be unpleasant. The ailerons are right where the flow separates, so the pilot feels buffet through the ailerons and has little, if any, roll control just when it is needed. If one tip stalls before the other, the lift lost far out on the span has a long lever arm, so a violent wing drop can follow, and a wing drop at the stall greatly increases the tendency to enter a spin. Meanwhile the root, still flying, keeps producing its wake-free flow, so there is no buffet on the tail to warn the pilot, and no strong nose-down pitching moment to take the aircraft out of the stall. Every one of the four good characteristics has been lost. So a tapered wing must be modified to make its root stall first.
Part 3 · The cures
Making a tapered wing stall at the root Method How it works Where Washout (geometric twist)Incidence decreases root to tip, so the tip works at a smaller α Whole span Section variation Thicker, more cambered sections with a higher CL max near the tip Tip Leading edge slots Re-energise the boundary layer; raise local CL max ; keep the ailerons working Tip Stall strips Small triangular strips that force separation at high α Root leading edge Sharper root section Smaller leading edge radius stalls earlier (costs some efficiency) Root Vortex generators Mix fast air into the boundary layer and delay separation Tip (and elsewhere)
Two strategies: delay the stall at the tip , or promote it at the root . Many aircraft use both.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
10
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To give a tapered wing good stall characteristics, the designer has two strategies: delay the stall at the tips, or promote it at the root, and many aircraft do both. Washout, a geometric twist that decreases the incidence from root to tip, makes the tip work at a smaller angle of attack than the root. Section variation puts thicker, more cambered sections with a higher C L max near the tips, so they stall later. Leading edge slots near the tips re-energise the boundary layer, raising the local C L max and keeping the ailerons effective. At the root, stall strips, small triangular strips on the leading edge, force separation to start there at high angles of attack; a sharper root section would do the same but costs efficiency at all times. And vortex generators mix high-energy air into the boundary layer to delay separation where they are fitted. We will look at each in turn.
Part 3 · The cures
Washout: twist the tip down Washout : a decrease in incidence from root to tip (geometric twist)At any aircraft attitude the tip meets the air at a smaller α than the root So the root reaches the critical angle first The chart: 4° of washout moves the peak local CL from near the tip to inboard Ailerons keep working; the stall gives nose drop and buffet root: +4° incidence tip: 0° washout: incidence (and so α) decreases root → tip 0 0.5 1 0.4 0.8 1.2 root → tip local CL ÷ CL — no twist: peak near the tip — 4° washout: peak inboard
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
11
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Washout is a geometric twist built into the wing: the angle of incidence decreases from the root to the tip. Look at the two sections at the top. With the root set at plus four degrees and the tip at zero, the tip always meets the airflow at four degrees less angle of attack than the root, whatever the attitude of the aircraft. So as the aircraft slows down and the angle increases, the root reaches its critical angle first while the tip still has a margin in hand. The chart below shows what this does to the highly tapered wing from earlier, again by lifting-line theory. Without twist, the local lift coefficient peaks out towards the tip, in red. With four degrees of washout, in green, the peak moves well inboard. That restores the good characteristics: the ailerons stay effective, the nose drops, and the root wake buffets the tail. The price is a slightly less efficient lift distribution in the cruise.
Part 3 · The cures
Leading edge slots near the tip A slot lets high-pressure air from below flow over the upper surface It re-energises (adds kinetic energy to) the boundary layer Separation is delayed to a higher α, raising local CL max Placed towards the tip , it delays tip stall and keeps the ailerons effective Slats and slots are covered fully with the high lift devices Leading edge slot near the tip slat high-pressure air from below flows up through the slot flow stays attached to the trailing edge Local CL max and stalling α raised at the tip: ailerons keep working
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
12
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
A leading edge slot is a gap behind a small aerofoil-shaped vane at the leading edge. At high angles of attack the pressure under the wing is much higher than over the top, so air flows up through the slot and out over the upper surface at high speed. That fast jet of air re-energises the boundary layer, adding kinetic energy to it, so the boundary layer can climb further up the adverse pressure gradient before it separates. The stall is delayed to a larger angle of attack and the local C L max increases. Put a slot along the outer part of the wing, ahead of the aileron, and two good things happen: the tip stall is delayed, so the root stalls first, and the aileron stays in attached flow, so roll control is kept right through the stall. Remember the exam wording: slots increase the stalling angle by delaying separation.
Part 3 · The cures
Stall strips: make the root go first Instead of protecting the tip, force the root to stall first A sharper root section would do it, but costs efficiency all the time Stall strips : small triangular strips on the inboard leading edge At high α the sharp edge promotes separation behind it In the cruise they have no effect on wing efficiency stall strip (root) plan view: inboard leading edge only strip High α: the sharp edge trips separation at the root first Cruise: no effect on efficiency
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
13
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The other approach is to make the root stall first on purpose. One way would be to use a section with a smaller leading edge radius at the root, which stalls at a lower angle of attack; but that section is less efficient at every angle, so it costs performance in the cruise. A neater solution is the stall strip: a small triangular strip fixed along the leading edge on the inboard part of the wing. At low and moderate angles of attack, in the cruise, the strip sits near the stagnation point and the flow passes smoothly round it, so it has no noticeable effect on the wing’s efficiency. But at high angles of attack the stagnation point moves down and back, and the sharp edge of the strip now sits in the flow round the nose. It trips the boundary layer and promotes early separation behind it. The root stalls first, giving buffet, nose drop and good aileron control.
Part 3 · The cures
Vortex generators re-energise the boundary layer Rows of small, thin aerofoil-shaped blades standing about 2.5 cm up from the surface Each generates a small vortex The vortices mix high-energy free-stream air into the boundary layer The re-energised boundary layer resists the adverse gradient: separation is delayed Used near the tips, and on swept wings , to delay tip stall Vortex generators: small blades about 2.5 cm tall Each sheds a vortex that stirs fast air into the boundary layer high-energy free stream without with VGs Fuller, more energetic boundary layer → separation delayed
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
14
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Vortex generators are rows of small, thin blades, each a little aerofoil, projecting about two and a half centimetres vertically into the airstream, usually in a line just behind the leading edge. Each blade is set at an angle to the flow, so like a tiny wing tip it sheds a small vortex. Those vortices stir the air: they bring fast, high-energy air from the free stream down into the slow boundary layer close to the skin, and carry tired air out. The velocity profile on the right shows the result: the boundary layer becomes fuller and more energetic near the surface. A boundary layer with more kinetic energy can push further against the adverse pressure gradient before it separates, so the stall is delayed. Vortex generators are used near the tips to delay tip stall, and they are common on swept wings. The exam phrase is that they reduce boundary layer separation.
Part 3 · Swept wings
Why a swept wing stalls at its tips Sweepback allows a higher maximum speed , but increases the tendency to tip stall Outboard sections sit further aft in a stronger suction field: an induced spanwise flow The boundary layer drifts outward from root to tip over the upper surface Thick, low-energy boundary layer collects at the tips, which separate first Tapering the swept wing adds to the effect boundary layer drifts outboard (induced spanwise flow, root → tip) tips stall first
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
15
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
A swept wing is fitted to allow a higher maximum speed, but it has a stronger tendency to stall first near the tips. The reason is the induced spanwise flow of the boundary layer. On a swept-back wing, each section further out lies further aft, and the strong suction over the upper surface is arranged in bands that run diagonally across the span. The slow air of the boundary layer, which has little momentum of its own, gets drawn sideways along those bands, from the root towards the tips. Watch the orange arrows: the boundary layer drifts outboard across the upper surface and piles up at the tips as a thick, tired layer with very little kinetic energy. That is exactly the kind of boundary layer that separates first, so the tips stall early. If the swept wing is also tapered, as almost all are, the effect is even stronger. And on a swept wing, a tip stall has a particularly nasty consequence in pitch.
Part 3 · Swept wings
Pitch-up: the swept wing’s dangerous reaction Centre of pressure moves forward CG CP before CP after tips (aft of the CG) lose lift first → nose-up moment Downwash moves onto the tail inboard wing still lifting: maximum downwash on the tailplane → less tail lift both → PITCH-UP → α rises further Pitch-up : CP forward plus more downwash on the tail raise the nose, raising α and spreading the stall. Recovery may be very difficult or impossible .
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
16
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
On a swept wing the tips are well behind the centre of gravity. When they stall first, the lift that remains is concentrated on the inboard wing, which is further forward, so the centre of pressure moves forward. Lift now acts ahead of where it was, giving a nose-up pitching moment, the opposite of the gentle nose drop of a rectangular wing. There is a second effect. With the lift concentrated inboard, the strongest downwash comes off the inner wing, and that is right in front of the tailplane. More downwash on the tail reduces the tail’s upward lift, or increases its download, which again pushes the nose up. Both effects together raise the nose rapidly, which increases the angle of attack, which stalls more of the wing. This is called pitch-up. It can end in a complete loss of pitch control from which recovery may be very difficult or even impossible, and it is a dangerous characteristic of many high-speed swept-wing aircraft.
Part 3 · Swept wings
Fences, vortilons and saw-tooth leading edges Wing fence : a thin chordwise plate on the upper surface, leading edge to trailing edge, that blocks the outward drift Vortilon : a smaller fence under the leading edge ; at high α it sheds a vortex over the top that acts as a fence Engine pylons of pod-mounted engines work the same waySaw-tooth leading edge : a step that sheds a strong vortex at high α (rare on modern jets)Plus vortex generators ; and at the root: stall strips , a modified section, Krueger flaps inboard fence drift stopped at the fence vortilon (or engine pylon) under the leading edge saw-tooth leading edge vortex acts as a fence
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
17
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Since the tip stall of a swept wing comes from the outward drift of the boundary layer, the cures try to stop that drift. A wing fence is a thin metal plate standing up from the upper surface, usually running from the leading edge to the trailing edge, which simply blocks the boundary layer from flowing further outboard. A vortilon is a smaller fence fitted under the leading edge. At high angles of attack it sheds a small but intense vortex that rolls up over the upper surface and acts as an aerodynamic fence. The pylons of pod-mounted engines under the wing do the same job. A saw-tooth leading edge, a sudden step in the leading edge, also sheds a strong vortex at high angles of attack, though it is rare on modern jet transports. Vortex generators help too. And the root can be encouraged to stall first with a modified root section, stall strips, or less efficient Krueger flaps on the inboard leading edge.
Part 4 · Deep stall
The super stall (deep stall) Tip stall causes pitch-up ; the higher α stalls more of the wing Drag rises, lift falls: the aircraft sinks at a nose-high attitude A downward flight path with a high nose means a very large α The separated wake immerses a high-set tailplane in low-energy, turbulent air Elevator effectiveness is lost : the pilot cannot lower the nose; the stall becomes stable flight path nose +14° α ≈ 49° wake engulfs the T-tail Elevator in dead air: cannot lower the nose Stable, locked-in "super stall"
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
18
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now we can put the pieces together. A swept-back wing stalls first at the tips, and because the tips are well aft of the centre of gravity, the nose pitches up. That automatic increase in angle of attack stalls more of the wing. Drag rises steeply, lift falls away, and the aircraft begins to sink, while the attitude stays nose high. With the nose high and the flight path inclined steeply downward, the angle of attack between them becomes enormous; in the drawing it is nearly fifty degrees. The broad wake of separated, turbulent air from the stalled wing now streams back exactly where a high-mounted T-tail sits. The elevator is immersed in low-energy air and loses its effectiveness, so the pilot cannot push the nose down to reduce the angle of attack. The aircraft settles into a stable, locked-in condition called the super stall or deep stall, sinking rapidly with no means of recovery.
Part 4 · Deep stall
Who is to blame: the wing, the tail, or the engines? Swept-back wing: major factor Tip stall and pitch-up drive the aircraft to the huge α in the first place. The swept wing is the major contributory factor.
T-tail: completes the trap A high tailplane sits in the wake at very high α, so the elevator cannot lower the nose.
Rear engines: not a cause They are only the reason the designer put the tail on top of the fin (DC-9, MD-80, 727, F28). By themselves they do not cause super stall.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
19
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
So who is to blame for the deep stall? Two features combine: the swept-back wing and the high-mounted T-tail. Of the two, the swept-back wing is the major contributory factor, because its tip stall and pitch-up are what drive the aircraft to such a large angle of attack in the first place. Reduce that tendency, with fences, vortilons, saw-tooth leading edges and vortex generators, or by making the root stall first, and the risk falls. The T-tail completes the trap, because at very high angles of attack it sits right in the wake of the stalled wing. Many types of this layout, such as the D C nine, the M D eighty, the Boeing seven two seven and the Fokker twenty-eight, also have engines mounted on the rear fuselage. But the rear engines only explain why the designer put the tailplane on top of the fin. In and of themselves, rear-mounted engines do not contribute to super stall.
Part 4 · Stall prevention
The stick pusher A design that shows super stall must have a device to prevent it ever stalling : a stick pusher Once such an aircraft starts to stall it is too late : too fast for a human to respond Attached to the elevator controls, it pushes the column forward to reduce α, typically about 80 lb Strong enough to work, not too strong to hold in a runaway; it can be dumped , and normally not reset in flight Disengages automatically once α is low enough; VSR ≥ push speed + 2 kt or 2%shaker pusher pitch-up begins angle of attack increasing → Too fast for a human: the pusher acts first ≈ 80 lb push to the elevator → actuator • stops itself once α is reduced • can be dumped if it fails (cannot normally be reset)
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
20
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
An aircraft design that shows super stall tendencies must be fitted with a device that prevents it from ever stalling: the stick pusher. Once such an aircraft begins to stall, it is already too late; the progression into the deep stall is too fast for a human to respond to, and once locked in the aircraft cannot be un-stalled. So the stick pusher acts first. The shaker warns first; if the angle keeps rising, the pusher fires before pitch-up can begin. It is an actuator attached to the elevator control system that physically pushes the control column forward, typically with a force of about eighty pounds. That is strong enough to be effective, yet not so strong that a pilot could not hold it in a runaway. If it malfunctions it can be dumped, and once dumped it cannot normally be reset in flight. As soon as the angle of attack falls below a suitable value, it disengages by itself.
Part 4 · Other layouts
Stall behaviour of canards Conventional layout: the wing stalls before the tailplane , so control and stability are kept Canard: a foreplane ahead of the main wing If the main wing stalls first : stability is lost If the foreplane stalls first : the nose drops and control is lost , and the wing never reaches its CL max Designers usually make the foreplane stall first, accepting a lower maximum lift Conventional tail wing stalls first → control and stability kept Canard (foreplane) foreplane main wing Foreplane stalls first: nose drops, control lost, CL max of the wing not reached Wing stalls first: stability lost
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
21
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Finally, a word on canards, where the horizontal surface is a foreplane ahead of the main wing instead of a tailplane behind it. With the conventional rear tail, the wing stalls before the tailplane, so the pilot keeps longitudinal control and the aircraft stays stable through the stall. A canard faces a dilemma. If the main wing stalls first, the lift is lost behind the centre of gravity, the nose pitches up and longitudinal stability is lost, which is dangerous. If the foreplane stalls first, the nose drops and the angle of attack reduces, which is safe, but the pilot has lost pitch control at that moment, and the main wing can never be taken up to its own C L max, so the maximum lift coefficient of the whole aircraft is reduced. Most canard designs choose the second option and accept the lower maximum lift.
Summary of devices
Wing design features at a glance Feature Where Effect on the stall Washout Whole span (tip incidence lower) Tip at smaller α → root stalls first Thicker, more cambered tip section Tip Higher local CL max → tip stall delayed Leading edge slot Tip Boundary layer re-energised → tip stall delayed, ailerons work Stall strip Root leading edge Separation forced at the root Vortex generators Tip / swept wing Boundary layer re-energised → separation delayed Fence, vortilon, pylon, saw-tooth Swept wing Spanwise drift stopped → tip stall and pitch-up delayed Krueger flaps inboard Swept wing root Less effective LE device at the root → root stalls first Stick pusher Control system Prevents the stall on deep-stall designs
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
22
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here is everything in one table. Washout runs along the whole span and puts the tip at a smaller angle of attack, so the root stalls first. A thicker, more cambered section at the tip raises the local C L max there. A leading edge slot at the tip re-energises the boundary layer, delaying the tip stall and keeping the ailerons effective. A stall strip on the root leading edge forces separation to begin there. Vortex generators re-energise the boundary layer and delay separation wherever they are fitted, especially towards the tips and on swept wings. On a swept wing, fences, vortilons, engine pylons and saw-tooth leading edges all stop the spanwise drift of the boundary layer and so delay the tip stall and pitch-up. Less efficient Krueger flaps on the inboard leading edge let the root stall first. And where the design still has a deep stall tendency, a stick pusher prevents the stall altogether.
Summary
What to take into the exam Section Small nose radius, thin, aft max thickness/camber: stall at smaller α, more sudden. Same section, same stall α.
Rectangular Root first: aileron effectiveness, nose drop, buffet, no violent wing drop. Downwash grows root → tip.
Tapered Tip first: aileron buffet, wing drop, spin risk, no nose drop. Cure: washout, tip section, slots, strips, VGs.
Swept Spanwise drift → tip stall → CP forward + tail downwash → pitch-up.
Swept-wing cures Fences, vortilons, pylons, saw-tooth, VGs; root: strips, section, Krueger flaps.
Deep stall Pitch-up, sink nose high, T-tail in wake, elevator useless. Swept wing is the major factor.
Stick pusher Prevents the stall. About 80 lb, can be dumped, self-disengages. VSR ≥ push + 2 kt/2%.
Canard Wing first: stability lost. Foreplane first: control lost and CL max reduced.
Chapter 11 · Wing Design and Stall Behaviour
23
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To sum up. A small leading edge radius, a thin section and maximum thickness and camber further aft give a stall at a smaller angle and a more sudden one, and a given section always stalls at the same angle. A rectangular wing stalls at the root, because downwash grows towards the tips, and gives the four good characteristics: aileron effectiveness, nose drop, buffet and no violent wing drop. A tapered wing tends to stall at the tips, with aileron buffet, wing drop and a spin risk, so it needs washout, better tip sections, slots, stall strips or vortex generators. A swept wing suffers spanwise drift, tip stall and pitch-up, cured with fences, vortilons, pylons, saw-tooth leading edges and vortex generators, and by helping the root stall first. Pitch-up plus a T-tail can lead to the deep stall, for which the swept wing is the major factor, and the cure is a stick pusher. On a canard, whichever surface stalls first, something is lost.