Principles of Flight · Chapter 26
Sweepback and Transonic Handling How designers push the critical Mach number up, what sweepback costs, and how crews handle Mach tuck, buffet boundaries and the coffin corner.
Λ 35° the wing only “feels” V cos Λ © 2026 eatpl.in. For the personal study of eatpl.in students only. Do not copy or distribute.
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
In the last lesson we met shock waves and the trouble they cause: shock stall, wave drag, buffet, centre of pressure shifts and weak controls. This lesson is about living with them. First, how designers push the critical Mach number higher, with thin wings, sweepback and supercritical sections, and what each costs. Then the tools that reduce the effects once shocks do form: vortex generators, the area rule and better controls. Then two things every jet pilot must understand: Mach tuck with the Mach trimmer that cures it, and the buffet boundaries that squeeze the speed range at high altitude into the coffin corner. We finish with aerodynamic heating and a sweepback fact sheet.
Roadmap
Pushing back the transonic problems Raise M crit thin, swept, supercritical Live with shocks VGs, area rule, controls Mach tuck and the Mach trimmer Buffet boundary coffin corner, 1.3 g margin 1 · Raise M crit Thin sections , sweepback and supercritical sections, and what each costs.
2 · Reduce the effects Vortex generators , the area rule , and controls that keep working.
3 · Mach tuck Why the nose drops above Mcrit , and the Mach trim system.
4 · Buffet boundaries Stall and buffet limits, the coffin corner , the 1.3 g margin, heating.
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
2
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
This lesson is in four parts. Part one is about raising the critical Mach number, so that shocks form later: thin sections, sweepback and supercritical sections, and the price paid for each. Part two covers ways to reduce the effects once shocks are present: vortex generators that keep the boundary layer attached, the area rule that reduces interference drag, and controls that keep working at high Mach numbers. Part three is Mach tuck, the nose down pitch that appears above the critical Mach number, and the Mach trim system that deals with it. Part four brings the low speed stall and the high speed buffet together into the buffet boundaries: how they squeeze the usable speed range at high altitude into the coffin corner, why airlines keep a margin of one point three g, and how to read a buffet onset chart. We end with aerodynamic heating and a sweepback fact sheet.
Why raise M crit?
Faster and cheaper means delaying the shocks Up to about Mcrit compressibility is not too serious; beyond it drag rises steeply. So designers raise Mcrit , then soften what happens above it.
Thin sections Less acceleration over the wing; Mcrit up . Costs lift, weight and space.
Sweepback The section feels only V cos Λ ; the most common method. Brings tip stall and Mach tuck.
Supercritical sections Flat top: shocks later and weaker ; allows less sweep and thicker wings.
Vortex generators Re-energise the boundary layer so it survives the shock with less separation .
Area rule Smooth cross-sectional area along the aircraft cuts transonic interference drag .
Better controls Slab tailplane, roll spoilers, powered controls with Mach-sensitive feel, Mach trim .
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
3
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Airlines want to fly as fast and as efficiently as possible, and we saw in the last lesson that shock waves bring a massive rise in drag and a list of handling problems. Up to about the critical Mach number, compressibility is not too serious. So the first aim is to raise the critical Mach number as far as possible, and there are three main ways: thin sections, sweepback, and supercritical sections. Once shocks do form, other devices reduce their effects. Vortex generators feed energy into the boundary layer so that it separates less behind the shock. The area rule shapes the aircraft so that its cross-sectional area changes smoothly from nose to tail, which cuts the transonic drag rise. And the controls are designed to keep working: all moving tailplanes, roll spoilers, powered controls with artificial feel, and a Mach trim system. We will take each in turn.
Part 1 · Thin sections
Thin wings raise M crit, at a price A lower thickness/chord ratio means less acceleration over the wing: Mcrit rises Example: 15% t/c, Mcrit ≈ 0.75; 5% t/c, about 0.85 But less lift : higher take-off and landing speeds, longer distances Thin wings need disproportionately wider spars : more structural weight Little room for fuel , high-lift devices and the main gear 15% thick M crit ≈ 0.75 5% thick M crit ≈ 0.85 But a thin wing gives: • less lift: higher take-off and landing speeds • wider, heavier spars for the same strength • little room for fuel, flap mechanisms and gear
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
4
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The simplest way to raise the critical Mach number is a thinner wing. With a lower thickness to chord ratio, the air does not have to accelerate as much to get round the section, so it reaches the speed of sound at a higher free stream Mach number. As an example, if a fifteen per cent thick wing has a critical Mach number of point seven five, a five per cent thick wing might reach about point eight five. But thin wings have real disadvantages. They produce less lift, so take-off and landing speeds and distances go up. For the same strength and stiffness, a thin wing needs disproportionately wider spars, which adds structural weight. And there is little room inside a thin wing for fuel, for the flaps and slats with their mechanisms, or for the main landing gear. So designers looked for a way to get the benefit without the penalties.
Sweepback
A swept wing only feels part of the airflow Split the free stream into a component normal to the leading edge and one along it The normal component, V cos Λ , sets the pressure distribution It is smaller than V, so the section reaches local M 1 later: Mcrit rises Example: M 0.85 with Λ = 35° → the section “sees” about M 0.70 Forward sweep works too, but bending and twisting make sweepback more practical V (free stream) V cos Λ sets the pressures V sin Λ along the span Λ = 35° M 0.85 × cos 35° ≈ M 0.70 “seen” by the section
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
5
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Sweepback is the most widely used way of raising the critical Mach number. Think of the free stream arriving at a swept leading edge and split it into two components. One is at right angles to the leading edge, and its size is V times the cosine of the sweep angle. The other runs along the leading edge, towards the tip. To a first approximation, the section only responds to the normal component: that is what sets the pressure distribution and the speeding up of the air over the wing. Because that component is smaller than the free stream, the local flow reaches Mach one at a higher free stream Mach number. With thirty five degrees of sweep, an aircraft at Mach point eight five has sections that feel only about Mach point seven. In practice the gain is less than this simple picture suggests, but it is large. Forward sweep gives a similar effect, but the way the wing bends and twists makes sweepback more practical.
Another way to see it
Sweep reduces the effective thickness ratio Measured along the airflow, a swept wing’s chord is longer for the same thickness So its effective t/c is smaller : nearly the benefit of a thin wing …without losing strength or fuel space Sweep angle : between the 25% chord line and a perpendicular to the root chordIts one purpose is to raise Mcrit ; everything else is a by-product streamwise chord (longer) chord normal to the edge free stream normal section: 12% streamwise: same thickness, longer chord ≈ 10% Sweep cuts the effective thickness/chord ratio
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
6
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here is another way to picture the same benefit. Compare the chord measured at right angles to the leading edge with the chord measured along the airflow. On a swept wing the streamwise chord is longer, but the thickness is the same, so the effective thickness to chord ratio seen by the air is smaller. A twelve per cent section swept by thirty five degrees behaves roughly like a ten per cent section in the streamwise direction. So sweepback gives almost the same aerodynamic advantage as a thin wing, without the loss of strength and fuel space. For the exam, learn the definition: the sweep angle is the angle between the line joining the twenty five per cent chord points and a line perpendicular to the root chord. And remember the fact sheet message: the purpose of sweepback is to raise the critical Mach number. Every other effect of sweep is a by-product, and most of them are disadvantages.
A useful by-product
Lower lift curve slope: a smoother ride A swept wing has a smaller lift curve slope : less CL per degree A vertical gust changes α; the swept wing’s CL , and so load factor , changes less Example: +3° gust at cruise CL 0.5: about 0.60 g straight, 0.49 g swept But the same effect means less CL at a given α and a lower CL MAX The swept wing must fly at a higher angle of attack , most noticeable at low speed 0 4 8 12 16 0.0 0.5 1.0 angle of attack (°) CL straight swept 35° gust: +3° ΔCL 0.30 ΔCL 0.25 At cruise CL 0.5: Δn ≈ 0.60 g straight, 0.49 g swept
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
7
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
One of the few genuine advantages of sweep is a lower lift curve slope. Each degree of angle of attack produces less lift coefficient than on a straight wing of the same section. Why does that help? A vertical gust changes the angle of attack, so on a wing with a shallow lift curve the change in lift coefficient, and so the change in load factor, is smaller. In the example, a three degree gust at a cruise lift coefficient of point five adds about point six g on a straight wing but only about point four nine g on a wing swept thirty five degrees. That is a smoother ride and lower structural loads in turbulence. The other side of the coin is that the swept wing gives less lift at any given angle of attack, has a lower maximum lift coefficient reached at a higher angle, and so has to be flown at a higher angle of attack, which is most noticeable at low speed.
The price of sweep
Disadvantages of sweepback Lower CL MAX Higher stall speed , longer take-off and landing distances.
Higher stalling α Risk of tail strike ; poor view from the flight deck; each tail area gives less stability.
Tip stall Tends to stall at the tips first : pitch-up , possible deep (super) stall .
Weaker TE devices Swept hinge lines make flaps and controls less effective ; inboard flap hinges may be straight.
Complex high lift Needs leading- and trailing-edge devices; the fin is swept to delay fin stall in sideslip.
Mach tuck Sweep increases the nose-down pitch above Mcrit ; a Mach trimmer is needed.
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
8
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now the price of sweep. First, a lower maximum lift coefficient, which means a higher stall speed and longer take-off and landing distances. Second, the maximum lift comes at a higher angle of attack. That makes the landing gear design harder because of the risk of a tail strike, it spoils the view from the flight deck on take-off and landing, and a given tail area contributes less to stability. Third, a swept wing tends to stall at the tips first, giving pitch-up and possibly a deep stall, also called a super stall. Fourth, trailing edge flaps and controls are less effective because their hinge lines are swept, so the inboard flap hinge line is sometimes made straight, and leading edge devices are added. Swept wings need complex high lift devices, and the fin is swept too, so that it does not stall at the larger sideslip angles that come with the higher stalling angle. Finally, sweep makes Mach tuck worse.
Tip stall and pitch-up
Swept wings stall at the tips first Spanwise flow thickens the boundary layer outboard : the tips stall first Lift is lost at the tips, which are behind the CG: the CP moves inboard and forward Result: pitch-up , which drives the wing deeper into the stall (possible super stall ) Cures: fences , vortilons , saw-tooth leading edge, weaker inboard LE devices Severe pitch-up requires a stick pusher ; near the stall use ailerons with coordinated rudder CP: in and forward tips stall first spanwise flow thickens the outboard boundary layer nose pitches up Cures: fences, vortilons, saw-tooth LE, washout Severe pitch-up: a stick pusher is required
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
9
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
A swept wing tends to stall at its tips first. On the upper surface the boundary layer drifts outboard along the span, so it gets thicker towards the tips and separates there first, helped by the higher local lift coefficients outboard. Now think about where the tips are. On a swept wing they are well behind the root, and behind the centre of gravity. When they stall, lift is lost at the back of the wing, so the centre of pressure moves inboard and forward, and the nose pitches up. That raises the angle of attack further and spreads the stall, which in the worst case leads to a deep, or super, stall. The cures are wing fences and vortilons that block the spanwise flow, a saw-tooth leading edge, and using less effective leading edge devices inboard so that the root stalls first. An aircraft with a marked pitch-up tendency must have a stick pusher. Near the stall, keep the wings level with ailerons and coordinated rudder, because rudder alone gives excessive rolling.
Sweepback fact sheet
Sweepback: purpose and by-products Item Effect of sweepback Purpose To raise Mcrit ; the benefit outweighs the by-products Stall Tip stall → pitch-up → possible super stall; fences, vortilons, saw-tooth; stick pusher Lift Less CL at a given α; lower CL MAX at a higher α ; smaller lift curve slope Gusts Less sensitive : a smaller change in load factor for a given gustStability Small positive contribution to directional stability; significant positive contribution to lateral stability Above Mcrit Nose-down pitch: Mach tuck , countered by a Mach trim system Controls and flaps Hinge lines not at right angles to the flow: less effective ; complex LE and TE high-lift devices
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
10
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Here is the sweepback fact sheet in one table. Its purpose is to raise the critical Mach number, and that benefit outweighs everything else. The stall: tip stall leading to pitch-up and possible super stall, cured with fences, vortilons and a saw-tooth leading edge, and backed up with a stick pusher. Lift: less lift coefficient at a given angle of attack, and a lower maximum lift coefficient reached at a higher angle, because the lift curve slope is smaller. Gusts: the swept wing is less sensitive, so a gust causes a smaller change in load factor. Stability: sweep makes a small positive contribution to directional stability and a significant positive contribution to lateral stability. Above the critical Mach number: a nose down pitch, Mach tuck, which must be countered by a Mach trim system. And because the hinge lines of flaps and controls are not at right angles to the airflow, they are less effective, so complex high lift devices are needed at both edges.
Supercritical sections
A flat top that delays and weakens the shock Blunt nose , large thickness , flat upper surface S-shaped camber line (negative camber forward, strong aft camber) and a thick trailing edge The flat top gives less acceleration : shocks form at a higher MFS When they do form they are smaller and weaker : less wave drag No sharp pressure jump at the rear: much more even loading Conventional section (12%) Supercritical section (about 17%) flat upper surface blunt nose aft camber (S-shaped camber line) thick TE Less acceleration over the top: shocks form later, and are smaller and weaker when they do More even loading; more room for structure and fuel
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
11
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The supercritical section is a more recent way of getting efficient transonic flight. Compared with a conventional section it has a blunt nose, a large thickness, a relatively flat upper surface, an S shaped camber line with negative camber at the front and strong positive camber at the rear, and a thick trailing edge. The key is the flat top. The air over a conventional section is speeded up strongly and reaches high local Mach numbers ending in a strong shock. Over the flattened upper surface it does not accelerate as much, so shocks form at a higher free stream Mach number, and when they do form they are smaller and weaker. With a weak shock there is no sharp pressure rise near the rear of the section, which gives a much more even loading along the chord, less shock induced separation and less wave drag. The strongly cambered rear part makes up the lift that the flat top gives away.
Supercritical: pros and cons
What a supercritical wing buys, and what it costs Advantages Disadvantages Shocks later and weaker: less sweep needed for a given cruise Mach, easing the sweep problems Negative camber at the front suits cruise, not low speed: lower CL MAX Thicker : stiffer and stronger for the weight, allowing a higher aspect ratio and less induced dragNeeds extensive leading-edge devices : Krueger flaps, slats, slots, variable-camber flaps More internal space for fuel Strong aft camber (aft loading) gives a large nose-down pitching moment Either more payload at today’s cruise speed (less fuel burn)… …which the tailplane must balance: trim drag …or a higher cruise Mach with the same payload and drag Shock-induced buffet may cause severe oscillations
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
12
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
So what does a supercritical wing buy? Because the shocks form later and are weaker, less sweep is needed for a given cruise Mach number, which reduces the problems of sweepback. Because it is thicker, it is stiffer and stronger for a given structural weight, which allows a higher aspect ratio and so less induced drag, and there is more room for fuel. An airline can use these gains in one of two ways: keep today’s cruise speed and burn less fuel, carrying more payload, or keep today’s payload and cruise at a higher Mach number with little or no increase in drag. The costs: the negatively cambered front suits cruise but not low speed, so maximum lift is lower and extensive leading edge devices are needed, such as Krueger flaps, slats, slots and variable camber flaps. The aft camber gives a large nose down pitching moment that the tail must balance, costing trim drag. And shock induced buffet can still cause severe oscillations.
Part 2 · Vortex generators
Vortex generators: re-energising the boundary layer Most compressibility problems come from separation behind the shock The shock adds to the adverse pressure gradient ; a tired boundary layer separates Vortex generators : small vanes or wedges in spanwise rows on the upper surfaceEach sheds a vortex that mixes fast outer air into the boundary layer, raising its kinetic energy Used ahead of control surfaces , and on subsonic aircraft wherever separation costs drag vortex generator tip vortices mix fast outer air into the boundary layer tired re-energised Higher-energy boundary layer gets through the shock’s pressure rise with much less separation Used ahead of control surfaces and wherever separation costs drag
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
13
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Most of the bad effects of compressibility come from the boundary layer separating behind the shock, the shock stall. Separation happens because the boundary layer loses kinetic energy as it pushes against an adverse pressure gradient, and the shock makes that gradient much worse. So if we can give the boundary layer more energy, it will separate less. Vortex generators do exactly that, very simply. They are small plates, vanes or wedges set in spanwise rows on the upper surface of the wing. Each one sheds a small vortex from its tip, and the vortex stirs fast moving air from outside the boundary layer down into it, raising its kinetic energy. The re-energised boundary layer can then pass through the shock with much less separation. They are usually placed ahead of control surfaces, to keep the controls effective, but can be used wherever separation is causing drag, including on subsonic aircraft where the shape of the surface causes steep adverse pressure gradients.
The area rule
Smooth the cross-sectional area from nose to tail Without the area rule nose → tail cross-sectional area wing hump tail hump With the area rule (waisted fuselage) nose → tail cross-sectional area smooth total area The transonic area rule : the total cross-sectional area along the aircraft should change smoothly . Any reasonably smooth distribution helps.
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
14
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
At transonic speeds a large part of the drag rise of a complete aircraft comes from interference between its components, mainly between the wing and the fuselage. Experiments showed that this interference drag depends on how the total cross-sectional area of the aircraft changes along its length, from nose to tail. On the left is an early design: a straight tube fuselage with the wing and tail simply added on. The total area jumps up where the wing joins, and again at the tail, giving humps in the area curve. On the right the fuselage has been waisted, made narrower where the wing and tail attach, so that the total area rises and falls smoothly. There is an optimum distribution, and designing to it as closely as possible is called the transonic area rule. No real aircraft matches it exactly, but any reasonably smooth area distribution reduces the transonic drag rise.
Part 3 · Mach tuck
Above M crit the nose wants to go down Shocks form first at the root (thicker): lift lost inboard, ahead of the CG On a swept wing the CP moves outboard and aft : a nose-down moment Less lift at the root means less downwash at the tail: tail α rises, more nose-down Called Mach tuck , high-speed tuck or tuck under It feeds on itself: nose down → faster → more tuck CG CP moves aft and outboard root shocks first: lift lost inboard, ahead of the CG less downwash at the tail → tail angle of attack rises Both effects pitch the nose down: Mach tuck
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
15
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
As speed rises beyond the critical Mach number, a swept wing jet develops a nose down pitching moment called Mach tuck, high speed tuck or tuck under. There are two causes. First, the wing root is usually thicker than the tip, so it has a lower critical Mach number and the shock induced separation starts there. Lift is lost inboard, at the front of a swept wing, ahead of the centre of gravity, so the centre of pressure moves outboard and, because the wing is swept, aft. Second, with less lift at the root there is less downwash behind it, so the tailplane, sitting in that downwash, sees a larger angle of attack. It produces more upward force, or less downward force, which also pushes the nose down. The danger is that the effect feeds on itself: the nose drops, the aircraft accelerates, the Mach number rises and the tuck gets stronger. Without correction it would limit the maximum operating speed of every modern jet.
Mach trim
Mach trim restores a stable stick force gradient A speed-stable aircraft needs an increasing push to go faster With Mach tuck the push falls above Mcrit , even becoming a pull : unstable gradient Mach trim (Mach-sensitive, high Mach only) adjusts longitudinal trim: elevator up , reduce tailplane incidence , or move the CG aft by fuel transferIt does more than cancel the trim change, so the push force still rises with Mach A T-tail clear of the downwash helps, but brings the deep stall risk 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 Mach number stick force PUSH PULL basic: unstable Mach trim input resultant: push still increases M crit
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
16
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
For an aircraft to be speed stable, the pilot must push harder on the stick to make it go faster. Mach tuck spoils this. Above the critical Mach number the push force needed falls off, and at high enough Mach numbers the pilot must actually pull to stop the aircraft accelerating further. That is an unstable stick force gradient, and it is potentially very dangerous. The cure is a Mach trim system. It senses Mach number and works only at high Mach numbers, adjusting the longitudinal trim in one of three ways depending on the manufacturer: deflecting the elevator up, reducing the incidence of the variable incidence tailplane, which means moving its leading edge down, or moving the centre of gravity aft by pumping fuel to a tail trim tank. It does slightly more than simply cancel the trim change, so the resultant curve, in green, keeps a push force that rises with Mach number. Mounting the tailplane on top of the fin, clear of the downwash, also helps, but brings the deep stall problem.
Controls at high Mach
Keeping control in the transonic range All-moving tailplane A slab tailplane changes the whole surface’s angle: effective even with a shock ahead of a hinge.
Roll spoilers Spoilers on the upper surface give roll control where ailerons lose effect (and avoid aileron reversal).
Vortex generators Placed ahead of control surfaces to keep the flow attached over them.
Buzz fixes Control buzz: narrow trailing-edge strips , dampers in the circuit, or a stiffer control circuit.
Powered controls High, changing loads: fully powered controls with artificial feel , often Mach-sensitive.
Mach trim Automatic trim at high Mach keeps the stick force gradient stable .
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
17
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
We saw in the last lesson that conventional trailing edge controls lose effectiveness in the transonic range, especially when a shock sits ahead of the hinge. Here are the remedies. An all moving, or slab, tailplane changes the angle of the whole surface, so it keeps working even when the flow over the rear is disturbed. Roll control spoilers on the upper surface give roll power where the ailerons become weak. Vortex generators placed ahead of control surfaces keep the flow attached over them. Control buzz, the oscillation caused by a shock moving over the hinge, can be cured by narrow strips along the trailing edge of the control, by dampers in the control system, or by making the control circuit stiffer. Because the control loads at high speed are large and change through the transonic range, the controls are normally fully power operated with artificial feel, often made sensitive to Mach number. And the Mach trimmer looks after the stick force gradient.
Part 4 · Buffet boundaries
Stall speed rises at high altitude Factors in the buffet boundaries: load factor , Mach , angle of attack , pressure altitude , weight , CG Climb at constant EAS: TAS up, a down, so Mach rises Above about M 0.4 CL MAX falls , so VS (EAS) rises Low down VS is constant; high up it increases with altitude Higher g : each boundary moves right (VS ∝ √n) 100 150 200 250 300 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 equivalent airspeed (kt) pressure altitude (ft) 1 g 1.3 g 1.6 g M 0.6 M 0.8 constant at low level (Mach too low to matter) rises at height: CL MAX falls with Mach
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
18
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Now bring the low speed stall and the high speed buffet together. Six factors decide where buffet begins: load factor, Mach number, angle of attack, pressure altitude, weight and the centre of gravity position. Start with the stall. If you climb at a constant equivalent airspeed, the true airspeed rises and the speed of sound falls, so the Mach number rises. At low Mach numbers the maximum lift coefficient is roughly constant, but above about Mach point four it falls. The one g stall speed depends on the maximum lift coefficient, so once the stall happens at a high enough Mach number, the stall speed in equivalent airspeed starts to rise. The graph shows the stall boundary for one g: vertical at low altitudes, where the stall speed is too low for compressibility to matter, then curving to higher speeds as you climb. Higher load factors give similar curves further right, because stall speed rises with the square root of the load factor.
The coffin corner
Low-speed and high-speed buffet close in with height 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 FL200 FL250 FL300 FL350 FL400 FL450 Mach number pressure altitude (ft) aerodynamic ceiling (1 g): “coffin corner” 1.3 g limit ≈ FL406 MMO 0.84 FL350, 1 g: from M 0.555 up to MMO low-speed buffet (stall) boundary high-speed buffet boundary 110 t, illustrative jet transport 1 g boundaries 1.3 g boundaries Above a certain altitude there is only one speed at which the aircraft can fly in 1 g: the aerodynamic ceiling , or coffin corner . Faster, slower or banking means buffet or stall.
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
19
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Stall sets a lower speed limit. For a high speed aircraft there is also an upper limit, set by the approach of shock stall and its buffet. Together they make the buffet boundaries, drawn here for a typical jet transport. The red curve on the left is the low speed boundary, the stall or low speed buffet. The red curve on the right is the high speed buffet boundary. As altitude increases they close in, for two reasons: the equivalent airspeed for a given Mach number falls, so the angle of attack needed rises, and that higher angle of attack lowers the Mach number at which buffet begins. Eventually the two curves meet. At that altitude there is only one speed at which the aircraft can fly in one g; any change of speed, a turn or a gust would stall it or buffet it. That is the aerodynamic ceiling, the coffin corner. The purple curves for one point three g meet much lower, at about flight level four zero five here.
Load factor and EAS
The speed–g envelope shrinks with altitude At sea level: stall boundary rises with √n to the limit load factor ; buffet is far to the right High up the stall boundary rises more steeply , because CL MAX falls with Mach The buffet boundary moves left : higher g needs higher α, lowering the buffet Mach Above some altitude the boundaries meet below the structural g limit : coffin corner again More g (bank or gust) means a more severe buffet limit 100 200 300 400 0 1 2 3 equivalent airspeed (kt) load factor n (g) maximum permissible g (2.5) sea level FL300 FL390 coffin corner below max g
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
20
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
The same limits can be drawn as load factor against equivalent airspeed. At sea level the stall boundary rises with the square root of the load factor until it meets the limit load factor, which must never be exceeded, and the high speed buffet boundary lies far out to the right. Inside the envelope you may fly any combination of speed and g. At altitude the picture changes. The stall speed in equivalent airspeed rises with g more quickly than at sea level, because the stall now happens at a Mach number where maximum lift is reduced. At the same time the buffet boundary moves left, because pulling g needs a higher angle of attack, which lowers the Mach number at which buffet begins. At flight level three nine zero in this example the two boundaries meet at about one point four g, well below the structural limit. That point is another way of showing the coffin corner. The message: the more g, from bank or gusts, the more severe the buffet limitation.
The buffet margin
Weight, CG and the 1.3 g margin Flying at the aerodynamic ceiling leaves no margin : the smallest gust or turn would buffet Regulations require a minimum buffet margin of 0.3 g : operate at or below the 1.3 g altitude 1.3 g is a 40° bank or a strong gust; normal high-level bank limit is 10–15° More weight : stall boundary right, buffet boundary left, less max g: all boundaries more restrictive Forward CG raises stall speed: the same effect as extra weight0 20 40 60 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 bank angle in a level turn (°) load factor n = 1 ÷ cos φ 1.3 g = 40° bank 1.7 g = 54° bank 1.3 g margin = 1 g + 0.3 g: a gust or a 40° bank can be sustained without buffet Normal high-altitude bank limit: about 10–15°
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
21
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Flying at the aerodynamic ceiling would leave no safety margin at all. In one g the aircraft would be permanently on the point of stalling, and it could neither turn nor ride the smallest gust without buffeting. So regulations require a minimum buffet margin of point three g. The aircraft is flown at or below the altitude at which one point three g can be pulled without buffet. In a level turn, load factor is one over the cosine of the bank angle, so one point three g is about forty degrees of bank, and the graph shows one point seven g is about fifty four degrees. Since normal high level bank angles are only ten to fifteen degrees, the margin is mostly there for gusts. Weight matters too. More weight raises the stall speed, moving the stall boundary right; it raises the angle of attack at any speed, moving the buffet boundary left; and it reduces the maximum permissible g. All the boundaries become more restrictive. A forward centre of gravity raises the stall speed and has the same effect as extra weight.
Using a buffet onset chart
A worked buffet onset chart Example data: M 0.80, FL350, 110 t, CG 30% , clean, MMO 0.84. Each answer is read by entering the chart and following the guide lines.
Question How it is read Answer Buffet onset at M 0.80, FL350 From M 0.80 and FL350 through weight and CG to the load factor scale 1.7 g , i.e. 54° bank 1.3 g altitude (110 t, 30%) Enter at 1.3 g, via 110 t and the 30% CG line, across to M 0.80 FL405 : above it a 40° bank or gust could buffetLow-speed buffet, 1 g at FL350 Enter at 1 g, via 110 t and 30% CG, to the FL350 curve, low-speed end M 0.555 High-speed buffet, 1 g at FL350 Same line, high-speed end: the curve does not reach it before MMO None below MMO 0.84 Aerodynamic ceiling at 150 t Enter at 1 g via 150 t, across to M 0.80 FL390
Check: n = 1/cos φ, so 1.7 g ↔ 54° and 1.3 g ↔ 40°. For Mach numbers of 0.82 and above, this example chart shows no CG effect.
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
22
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
A buffet onset chart combines all these factors so the crew can check their margin. Take the example: Mach point eight zero at flight level three five zero, one hundred and ten tonnes, centre of gravity thirty per cent. Reading from Mach point eight and the flight level through the weight and CG corrections to the load factor scale gives buffet onset at one point seven g, which is fifty four degrees of bank. Entering at one point three g instead and working back gives the one point three g altitude: flight level four zero five. Above that, a forty degree bank or a gust of that size could cause buffet. Entering at one g and following to the flight level three five zero curve gives the low speed buffet at Mach point five five five, and at the high speed end the curve does not reach the line before Mach point eight four, the maximum operating Mach number, so M M O is the limit. Finally, at one hundred and fifty tonnes, the aerodynamic ceiling at Mach point eight is about flight level three nine zero.
Aerodynamic heating
Fast air heats the skin Air heats up when it is compressed or rubbed by friction On an aircraft: the stagnation point , through shock waves , and in the boundary layer The rise grows with M² : about 40 °C at M 1 It matters for the structure from about M 2 , the limit for conventional aluminium alloys Beyond M 2: heat treatment and fatigue life suffer, so titanium or stainless steel 0 1 2 3 4 0 200 400 600 Mach number temperature rise at the stagnation point (°C) +43 °C +173 °C +390 °C aluminium alloys up to about M 2 titanium or stainless steel stratosphere, −56.5 °C; skin values are a little lower
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
23
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
Air gets hotter when it is compressed and when it is subjected to friction, and an aircraft does both. The air is compressed at the stagnation points and through shock waves, and it is heated by friction in the boundary layer. So the skin of a fast aircraft warms up. This happens at all speeds, but it only matters for the structure at higher Mach numbers. The temperature rise grows with the square of the Mach number. In the stratosphere it is about forty degrees at Mach one, about one hundred and seventy at Mach two and nearly four hundred at Mach three; the skin itself runs a little cooler than the full stagnation value. Around Mach two the heating starts to affect the heat treatment of aluminium alloys and to shorten their fatigue life, so Mach two is roughly the limit for conventional light alloy construction. Faster aircraft need titanium or stainless steel.
Summary
What to take into the exam Raise M crit Thin sections (15% ≈ 0.75, 5% ≈ 0.85), sweep (V cos Λ), supercritical (flat top, weak shocks).
Sweep costs Lower CL MAX , higher stall α, tip stall → pitch-up , weak TE devices; but less gust-sensitive .
Stability Sweep: small + directional , significant + lateral stability. Sweep angle at the 25% chord line.
VGs and area rule VGs re-energise the boundary layer; area rule: smooth area distribution, waisted fuselage.
Mach tuck Root shocks first: CP aft (swept), less downwash at tail: nose down ; unstable stick force.
Mach trim Mach-sensitive, high Mach only: elevator up, less tailplane incidence or CG aft .
Buffet boundaries Close in with altitude, weight, g, forward CG; meet at the coffin corner . Keep a 1.3 g margin.
Controls and heat Slab tail, spoilers, powered controls, buzz fixes. Heating ≈ 40 °C at M 1; Al limit about M 2.
Chapter 26 · Sweepback and Transonic Handling
24
e-books by eatpl.in · © 2026 · Do not copy or distribute
To sum up. To raise the critical Mach number, use thin sections, sweepback, which works because the section only feels V cos lambda, and supercritical sections with their flat tops and weak shocks. Sweep costs maximum lift, raises the stalling angle, brings tip stall and pitch-up and weakens trailing edge devices, but it makes the aircraft less sensitive to gusts, and it adds a small amount of directional and a significant amount of lateral stability. Vortex generators re-energise the boundary layer; the area rule smooths the cross-sectional area along the aircraft. Mach tuck comes from the root shocking first, moving the centre of pressure aft on a swept wing and reducing the downwash at the tail, giving a nose down pitch and an unstable stick force gradient, which the Mach trimmer corrects. The buffet boundaries close in with altitude, weight, load factor and a forward centre of gravity, meeting at the coffin corner, so airlines keep a one point three g margin.